STREAMING NOW: Watch Now

Pope revives lapsed sex abuse commission amid skepticism

(L'Osservatore Romano/Pool Photo via AP). Pope Francis celebrates Mass at the Santa Marta chapel at the Vatican, Friday, Feb. 16, 2018.

Pope Francis revived his lapsed sex abuse advisory commission by naming new members Saturday, after coming under fire for his overall handling of the scandal and his support for a Chilean bishop accused by victims of witnessing and ignoring their abuse.

Posted: Feb 17, 2018 11:46 AM

VATICAN CITY (AP) - Pope Francis revived his lapsed sex abuse advisory commission by naming new members Saturday, after coming under fire for his overall handling of the scandal and his support for a Chilean bishop accused by victims of witnessing and ignoring their abuse.

The announcement of the new members of the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors came on the same day that a Vatican investigator will take the testimony in New York of one of the main whistleblowers in the Chilean cover-up scandal.

Francis tasked Archbishop Charles Scicluna with the fact-finding mission into Bishop Juan Barros after he came under blistering criticism in Chile for defending Barros and calling the victims' cover-up accusations against him slander.

The initial three-year mandate of commission members had lapsed two months ago, on Dec. 17. Francis named nine new members Saturday and kept seven from the initial group. A Vatican statement said survivors of abuse are included, but didn't identify them to protect their privacy.

None of the most outspoken lay advocates for victims from the original group returned, but a statement stressed that the commission's work would be imbued throughout with the experience of victims.

Commission members are to open their April plenary by meeting with victims privately, and discussions are continuing to create an "international survivor advisory panel" to advise the commission and make sure the voices of victims are heard in all its deliberations, the statement said.

The new members are noteworthy for their geographic representation, hailing from Tonga, Brazil, Ethiopia and Australia, among other places.

"The newly appointed members will add to the commission's global perspective in the protection of minors and vulnerable adults," said Cardinal Sean O'Malley, the commission's president.

Francis has insisted he has "zero tolerance" for abuse and had pledged to hold bishops accountable when they botch cases. But there have been several well-known cases where he and the Vatican sided with the accused over victims, calling into question whether he shares the "victims first" policy that guides his own commission's work.

The Barros case is the most prominent example. Victims of Chile's most notorious predator priest, the Rev. Fernando Karadima, have for years accused Barros of witnessing their abuse, ignoring it and defending Karadima.

En route home from Chile, though, Francis insisted he had no "evidence" against Barros to warrant removing him. The Associated Press, though, reported that he received a letter from a Karadima victim, Juan Carlos Cruz, in April 2015 detailing the abuse he suffered and Barros' presence while it happened.

Francis' defiant defense of Barros suggested that he find Cruz or the other victims credible, and believed instead Barros' ecclesial supporters in Chile and at the Vatican.

Cruz testifies Saturday before Scicluna, who was the architect of the Vatican's get-tough approach to sex abuse in the early 2000s. Several recent cases, however, indicate that the Vatican under Francis doesn't favor the "one strike and you're out" approach adopted by the U.S. bishops, for example, after the scandal exploded there in 2002.

Francis himself has admitted that he opts to give offenders the benefit of the doubt, especially when solid proof - often hard to come by in decades-old sex abuse cases - is lacking.

"As must be done in good jurisprudence, always in favor of the offender," he told reporters Jan. 21 en route home from South America.

Francis applied that concept in the case of the Rev. Mauro Inzoli, a well-known Italian priest defrocked by the Vatican for having abused children as young as 12. He had his sentence reduced on appeal to a lifetime of penance and prayer in 2014 after what his bishop said was a show of mercy from Francis. But in 2016, an Italian judge convicted Inzoli of abusing five children aged 12-16 and sentenced him to four years, nine months in prison. The Vatican opened a new church trial against him and in 2017 he was definitively defrocked.

Francis has held out the Inzoli case as an exception, where he opted for a lesser sanction.

But Italy's Il Mattino newspaper has had a series of exposes about another case where the Vatican under Francis opted to take the priest's word over that of the victim's.

The victim in that case accused the Rev. Silverio Mura, a parish priest in Ponticelli, of raping him as a 13-year-old. He came forward in 2010 to accuse Mura, after remembering the abuse during the therapy he was undergoing for the panic attacks, depression and other medically certified reactions to his childhood trauma.

But the case, investigated by the archdiocese of Naples, was shelved in 2016 for lack of proof.

The victim had declined to submit to a second diocesan psychiatric evaluation after the first one subjected him to a "savage" police-style interrogation that sought to destroy his fragile defenses, according to a letter to the archdiocese' psychiatrist from the victim's personal psychiatrist, Dr. Alfonso Rossi.

Il Mattino this month reported, however, that other victims have since come forward alleging similar rapes.

Vatican spokesman Greg Burke confirmed Saturday that the case was now revived, on the express wishes of Francis. He said it had never been archived, just dormant "awaiting other elements of proof."

Il Mattino, however, reported Feb. 4 that the priest had been sanctioned based on the evidence already given. "Quickly admonish the priest," was the recommendation included in the file in the archives of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Il Mattino reported.

Copyright 2018 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Terre Haute
Clear
40° wxIcon
Hi: 71° Lo: 39°
Feels Like: 40°
Robinson
Clear
37° wxIcon
Hi: 69° Lo: 39°
Feels Like: 37°
Indianapolis
Partly Cloudy
45° wxIcon
Hi: 69° Lo: 41°
Feels Like: 45°
Rockville
Partly Cloudy
40° wxIcon
Hi: 70° Lo: 39°
Feels Like: 40°
Casey
Partly Cloudy
39° wxIcon
Hi: 70° Lo: 42°
Feels Like: 39°
Brazil
Partly Cloudy
40° wxIcon
Hi: 70° Lo: 40°
Feels Like: 40°
Marshall
Partly Cloudy
40° wxIcon
Hi: 70° Lo: 38°
Feels Like: 40°
More Clouds & Warmer Friday
WTHI Planner
WTHI Temps
WTHI Radar

Latest Video

Image

West Vigo beats Clay City

Image

Northview boys win WIC Track & Field Title

Image

Wyatt Bowden defying the odds on the track

Image

Lupus Awareness Month

Image

NaloxBox seeing results in Vincennes

Image

COVID-19 vaccines and children

Image

There's rain in the forecast - Kevin explains here

Image

Five local groups receive a boost in funding thanks to Duke Energy

Image

Safe travel and COVID-19

Image

After putting their 2020 event on hold - Pedal Putnam set for this fall

WTHI Events

 

Illinois Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 7 p.m. CT)

Cases: 1359651

Reported Deaths: 24640
CountyCasesDeaths
Cook54427910087
DuPage903871277
Will75352989
Lake67029987
Kane58265770
Winnebago33136473
Madison30469519
McHenry28511285
St. Clair27822513
Peoria23054306
Champaign20597145
Sangamon18698234
McLean18114178
Tazewell16913283
Rock Island14943313
Kankakee14147210
Kendall1299793
LaSalle12516243
Macon10733198
DeKalb9846119
Vermilion9603132
Adams8439123
Williamson7416129
Whiteside7155171
Boone669472
Ogle609781
Grundy587375
Clinton575590
Coles567694
Knox5543142
Jackson501564
Henry495365
Livingston481585
Stephenson474482
Effingham472972
Woodford472876
Macoupin469082
Marion4471115
Franklin444774
Monroe435693
Jefferson4288120
Lee415952
Randolph412884
Fulton391255
Morgan388781
Logan386258
Bureau371582
Montgomery371474
Christian365773
Fayette316955
Perry316360
Iroquois301366
McDonough283747
Jersey268949
Douglas258635
Saline256354
Lawrence240425
Shelby229537
Union225740
Crawford211626
Bond204624
Cass199025
Jo Daviess180724
Warren179746
Clark179433
Pike178852
Ford177946
Wayne177352
Hancock175731
Carroll175036
Richland174840
Edgar169839
White169426
Washington164025
Moultrie160928
De Witt150824
Mason150545
Piatt149414
Clay148143
Mercer146633
Johnson143715
Greene143633
Wabash134512
Massac133840
Cumberland129019
Menard123312
Jasper115018
Marshall106618
Hamilton83115
Schuyler7526
Brown7046
Pulaski6877
Stark63423
Edwards56812
Henderson52514
Calhoun5182
Putnam4813
Scott4781
Alexander46811
Gallatin4584
Hardin38612
Pope3194
Out of IL20
Unassigned02355

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 8 p.m. ET)

Cases: 731810

Reported Deaths: 13445
CountyCasesDeaths
Marion1001261745
Lake53835974
Allen40734678
St. Joseph35782552
Hamilton35659408
Elkhart28633442
Tippecanoe22412219
Vanderburgh22318397
Porter18795308
Johnson17989379
Hendricks17255315
Clark12996191
Madison12688339
Vigo12464247
LaPorte11948211
Monroe11907170
Delaware10710186
Howard9936216
Kosciusko9426117
Hancock8301141
Bartholomew8073156
Warrick7785155
Floyd7670178
Grant7067174
Wayne7056199
Boone6704101
Morgan6582139
Dubois6161117
Marshall6062111
Dearborn581778
Cass5816105
Henry5738103
Noble562284
Jackson502373
Shelby492696
Lawrence4559120
Harrison436272
Gibson435792
DeKalb428885
Clinton427853
Montgomery424289
Whitley396739
Huntington392280
Steuben388657
Miami381967
Knox372090
Jasper366548
Putnam361260
Wabash354480
Adams341754
Ripley339970
Jefferson331281
White314554
Daviess297999
Wells291881
Decatur285492
Fayette281062
Greene279385
Posey271833
LaGrange267470
Scott266654
Clay260347
Washington241332
Randolph240781
Spencer232431
Jennings230149
Starke217054
Fountain212946
Sullivan211942
Owen200856
Jay195830
Fulton195440
Carroll189420
Orange183754
Perry183037
Rush173425
Vermillion169343
Franklin168235
Tipton163045
Parke146416
Blackford135032
Pike134734
Pulaski116845
Newton108034
Brown102341
Crawford100015
Benton98814
Martin89215
Warren82115
Switzerland7918
Union71010
Ohio56811
Unassigned0417