Judge’s ruling slows plans for Medicaid work requirement

The Trump administration’s drive to wean poor people from government benefits by making them work has been slowed by a federal judge framing a fundamental question: Are poverty programs meant to show tough love or to help the needy?

Posted: Jul 5, 2018 8:31 AM

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Trump administration’s drive to wean poor people from government benefits by making them work has been slowed by a federal judge framing a fundamental question: Are poverty programs meant to show tough love or to help the needy?

U.S. District Judge James E. Boasberg in Washington last week halted Kentucky’s first-in-the-nation experiment with Medicaid work requirements, ruling that the Trump administration glossed over potential coverage losses. He sent the state’s plan back to federal authorities for a harder look.

The debate goes well beyond Medicaid, the federal-state health program for low-income and disabled people.

This spring, President Donald Trump signed an executive order directing cabinet agencies to add or strengthen work requirements for programs including subsidized housing, food stamps and cash welfare. The government’s biggest assistance program for low-income people — the Earned Income Tax Credit — is already designed to supplement earnings from work.

Boasberg found that “medical assistance” is by law a “central objective” of Medicaid. While work requirements might be allowable if that’s what a state wants, “there may be limits to how much (coverage) loss is too much,” he wrote.

Kentucky’s Republican Gov. Matt Bevin wanted to impose work requirements on some 428,000 state residents who got Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act’s expansion. Optional for states, the expansion passed under former President Barack Obama covers about 12 million people nationally, mainly adults.

Kentucky expanded Medicaid under a Democratic governor. Bevin argues that the cost is unsustainable for his state, even with Washington paying at least 90 percent of the bill, because many more people signed up than initially expected. The state estimated that work requirements would save money, reducing the Medicaid rolls by about 95,000 people over five years.

That number got the judge’s attention.

Boasberg ruled that the federal Health and Human Services department didn’t dig deeply enough into the potential coverage losses. The department “paid no attention to that deprivation,” he wrote, and “this oversight is glaring,” amounting to rubber-stamping the state’s request.

Although state and federal officials contend that many people leaving Medicaid would find private coverage, Boasberg said there was no hard analysis, no “bottom-line estimate.”

The ruling seemed to catch the Trump administration unprepared.

Seema Verma, head of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, called it “disappointing.” The administration may appeal, or it may re-run its evaluation of the Kentucky plan to meet the judge’s concerns. Medicaid work requirements in a few other states are unaffected.

However, the ruling may make it much harder to approve work requirements in states that have not expanded Medicaid. In such states, Medicaid recipients would face a high risk of losing health care because even paltry earnings could make them ineligible for continued coverage.

Verma said the administration won’t be deterred from nudging the poor to go to work.

“We will continue to support innovative, state-driven policies that are designed to advance the objectives of the Medicaid program by improving health outcomes for thousands of low-income Americans,” she said in a statement. Work improves health, the administration argues.

The nonpartisan Kaiser Family Foundation estimates that about 60 percent of adults with Medicaid are already working, and among those not working, most either have health problems, are taking care of home or family or are students.

Advocates for low-income people say they feel like a corner has been turned, even if the issue is far from settled.

“What’s particularly significant is that the judge basically said you have to look at the purpose of Medicaid, which is to provide coverage,” said Judy Solomon of the nonprofit Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. Work requirements “were outside the core objectives of the Medicaid program, and he basically said you can’t ignore the core objectives.”

Others point out that the judge stopped short of deciding the merits of the case, focusing instead on problems with the process that HHS followed in approving Kentucky’s request.

Matt Salo, executive director of the nonpartisan National Association of Medicaid Directors, said work requirements may serve the purposes of Medicaid in some states, particularly if that helps convince conservative lawmakers to expand coverage to more uninsured people.

“There’s a broader issue at play here about maintaining political support and the sustainability of the program,” said Salo. “Does the inability to do a work requirement lead to a scenario where Kentucky is going to get rid of the entire expansion?”

So far that hasn’t happened, but Bevin did cut Medicaid dental and vision coverage in response to the judge’s ruling.

The case is Stewart vs. Azar.

Terre Haute
Clear
73° wxIcon
Hi: 77° Lo: 45°
Feels Like: 73°
Robinson
Clear
69° wxIcon
Hi: 78° Lo: 44°
Feels Like: 69°
Indianapolis
Partly Cloudy
70° wxIcon
Hi: 74° Lo: 47°
Feels Like: 70°
Rockville
Partly Cloudy
73° wxIcon
Hi: 76° Lo: 44°
Feels Like: 73°
Casey
Clear
73° wxIcon
Hi: 77° Lo: 47°
Feels Like: 73°
Brazil
Clear
73° wxIcon
Hi: 76° Lo: 45°
Feels Like: 73°
Marshall
Clear
73° wxIcon
Hi: 78° Lo: 45°
Feels Like: 73°
Clear & Cool
WTHI Planner
WTHI Temps
WTHI Radar

Latest Video

Image

The COVID-19 booster shot

Image

Vigo County Veteran's Court graduates 40th member

Image

A little rain chance - and then nice. Here's look at the weekend forecast

Image

Terre Haute church works to collect items for evacuated Afghan kids

Image

The Paris Honey Bee Festival

Image

Explore Wabashiki

Image

Pow Wow Day in Vigo County

Image

Daviess County offers $5,000 to people to move to the community

Image

Workforce Fit

Image

Duke Energy plans to bring solar farms to Sullivan County

WTHI Events

 

Illinois Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 7 p.m. CT)

Cases: 1608825

Reported Deaths: 27176
CountyCasesDeaths
Cook61448710970
DuPage1040741359
Will874621090
Lake772361061
Kane65993851
Winnebago39106545
Madison38249578
St. Clair35065570
McHenry33116316
Peoria26021362
Champaign25923183
Sangamon24663271
McLean21935208
Tazewell19792326
Rock Island17877346
Kankakee16821235
Kendall15501107
Macon14525244
LaSalle14520275
Vermilion13288190
Adams12718148
DeKalb11695129
Williamson11483159
Whiteside7925176
Jackson772889
Boone761282
Coles7381113
Ogle715787
Grundy702881
Franklin691399
Clinton682098
Knox6677164
Marion6559138
Macoupin649399
Henry624074
Jefferson6086132
Effingham608582
Livingston572896
Woodford555191
Stephenson548889
Randolph530297
Monroe509199
Christian493980
Fulton489670
Morgan488196
Logan478674
Montgomery469276
Lee459558
Bureau428388
Perry415871
Saline411764
Fayette401358
Iroquois395873
McDonough356256
Jersey323153
Shelby315643
Douglas307336
Crawford306030
Lawrence301931
Union297147
Wayne274657
White266830
Richland263255
Hancock258434
Pike256856
Clark251938
Cass251528
Bond244424
Clay240747
Edgar236345
Ford235656
Warren226061
Carroll225837
Johnson214424
Moultrie212431
Jo Daviess206926
Washington206227
Wabash201616
Greene200939
Mason200151
Massac199544
De Witt196330
Piatt191414
Mercer191234
Cumberland179325
Menard159812
Jasper153118
Marshall134921
Hamilton129521
Brown10198
Pulaski98711
Schuyler9728
Edwards96615
Stark77027
Gallatin7496
Scott6975
Alexander67811
Henderson65614
Calhoun6452
Hardin56114
Putnam5454
Pope4845
Unassigned1892432
Out of IL80

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 8 p.m. ET)

Cases: 944708

Reported Deaths: 15343
CountyCasesDeaths
Marion1287051987
Lake634321097
Allen53759760
Hamilton43980448
St. Joseph42010590
Elkhart33651491
Vanderburgh30486449
Tippecanoe26872250
Johnson23685417
Hendricks22354341
Porter21799347
Clark17493231
Madison17439384
Vigo16209284
Monroe14515191
LaPorte14350239
Delaware14134222
Howard13921273
Kosciusko11448135
Hancock10886166
Warrick10715177
Bartholomew10589169
Floyd10471206
Wayne10020226
Grant9165204
Morgan8895160
Boone8417111
Dubois7748123
Dearborn764990
Henry7648130
Noble7435101
Marshall7384128
Cass7209117
Lawrence6999153
Shelby6616111
Jackson659186
Gibson6177107
Harrison606286
Huntington603195
Montgomery5830105
DeKalb578391
Knox5506104
Miami545788
Putnam540568
Clinton535965
Whitley526553
Steuben499768
Wabash486292
Jasper481860
Jefferson472892
Ripley456077
Adams445568
Daviess4209108
Scott407965
White392957
Clay392857
Greene390592
Wells388784
Decatur385996
Fayette377278
Posey361541
Jennings354356
Washington333747
LaGrange323575
Spencer319536
Fountain317955
Randolph314889
Sullivan308449
Owen284863
Starke281464
Fulton280054
Orange276859
Jay256338
Perry252552
Carroll244929
Franklin240538
Rush235630
Vermillion234450
Parke221020
Tipton210555
Pike209539
Blackford169634
Pulaski165551
Crawford146718
Newton145245
Benton143516
Brown135546
Martin129317
Switzerland126210
Warren115516
Union97711
Ohio80111
Unassigned0479