Indiana lawmakers advance bill allowing health order appeals

Indiana lawmakers on Wednesday advanced legislation that would make it easier to overturn local health orders or enforcement actions amid ongoing complaints from conservatives about Republican Gov. Eric Holcomb’s statewide response to the coronavirus.

Posted: Mar 31, 2021 4:50 PM

INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — Indiana lawmakers on Wednesday advanced legislation that would make it easier to overturn local health orders or enforcement actions amid ongoing complaints from conservatives about Republican Gov. Eric Holcomb’s statewide response to the coronavirus.

Holcomb responded with concern about the bill’s progress and said he also expects to veto a separate measure approved by lawmakers on Monday that would curb the governor’s authority under the state emergency powers law.

The Senate bill creates a process allowing the public to appeal local health orders to county or city elected board. Such orders could include citations, fines or an order to close a business. The enforcement action would be halted during an appeal, which could allow a business to stay open until the matter is heard by a city or county board, even if it is not following health orders.

Currently, the only option is to file a lawsuit. The appeals process would apply only to health orders enacted during a declared emergency.

Language added to the proposal by House lawmakers requires that any local emergency health order that is more stringent than state orders must first be approved by local elected officials, like city council members or county commissioners.

The bill also makes it easier for local elected officials to remove health officers, including for “good cause” alone.

The amended measure was approved by the House rules committee Wednesday and now heads to the full chamber for consideration.

Bill author Republican Sen. Chris Garten, of Charlestown, said the legislation isn’t meant to be a combative response against local health officials, but rather a “check and balance” that protects the rights of business owners and ensures economic health.

Democrats have argued that the plan gives politicians too much control over major public health decisions and puts public health in jeopardy. Rep. Matt Pierce, a Democrat from Bloomington, emphasized that the enforcement appeals are likely to be influenced by partisan politics and “won’t be about the science.”

More than 60 executive orders issued by Holcomb since Indiana’s first confirmed COVID-19 case was announced last March have stirred some conservative opposition and prompted debate in the GOP-dominated Legislature on measures limiting the governor’s authority to impose emergency restrictions.

Holcomb announced last week that he would lift the statewide mask mandate and remaining COVID-19 business restrictions on April 6. He pointed to the ability of local officials to impose tougher restrictions in response to COVID-19 cases in their communities as a justification for the step.

The governor said Wednesday that makes the implications of the legislation on local units “concerning” and noted that he would “take a hard look” at the language of the bill.

He added that he has concerns with “multiple” other bills moving through the Legislature, including a proposal to limit a governor’s authority to impose long-lasting emergency restrictions, such as mask rules and business closures.

The House bill would also establish a new process for the General Assembly to call itself into a 40-day emergency session to consider legislative action in response to a gubernatorial declaration of a statewide emergency, a change to state law which Holcomb and some legal experts have maintained is beyond the Legislature’s control to make.

“I cannot skirt my duty and do something that I believe is unconstitutional. ... It’s v-e-t-o,” Holcomb said Wednesday. “All these bills that have anything to do with how we manage our way through this thorny period in our state’s history concern me.”

Lawmakers could give final approval to the governor’s power bill as early as Thursday. Holcomb would have seven days to sign or veto it — or it would then become law without his signature. That could give the Legislature time to override a potential veto by a simple majority of both houses before the current session ends in late April.

The House committee additionally amended and approved a separate bill Wednesday that would designate religious activities as essential services and prohibit any restrictions on them during a declared emergency, including in-person services.

__

Casey Smith is a corps member for the Associated Press/Report for America Statehouse News Initiative. Report for America is a nonprofit national service program that places journalists in local newsrooms to report on undercovered issues.

Terre Haute
Mostly Cloudy
46° wxIcon
Hi: 63° Lo: 36°
Feels Like: 46°
Robinson
Clear
42° wxIcon
Hi: 61° Lo: 36°
Feels Like: 42°
Indianapolis
Cloudy
50° wxIcon
Hi: 63° Lo: 35°
Feels Like: 50°
Rockville
Cloudy
46° wxIcon
Hi: 64° Lo: 34°
Feels Like: 41°
Casey
Partly Cloudy
46° wxIcon
Hi: 61° Lo: 38°
Feels Like: 42°
Brazil
Mostly Cloudy
46° wxIcon
Hi: 63° Lo: 35°
Feels Like: 46°
Marshall
Partly Cloudy
46° wxIcon
Hi: 62° Lo: 34°
Feels Like: 46°
Another Chilly Night
WTHI Planner
WTHI Temps
WTHI Radar

Latest Video

Image

Marshall baseball beats Casey-Westfield

Image

Hagen Knepp Earns Junior All-Star Selection

Image

THN Boys win Travis Smith Vigo County Golf Match

Image

Casey-Westfield softball beats Marshall

Image

Casey-Westfield softball beats Marshall

Image

Lincoln Hale Commits to Indiana Wesleyn

Image

Rick's Rallies

Image

Vincennes Parks Superintendent Steve Beamon resigns from department

Image

Legislature votes to override governor's veto

Image

Parke County Community Crossings grant

WTHI Events

 

Illinois Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 7 p.m. CT)

Cases: 1354869

Reported Deaths: 24577
CountyCasesDeaths
Cook54245010056
DuPage900321276
Will75056989
Lake66830984
Kane58044770
Winnebago32927472
Madison30392518
McHenry28413285
St. Clair27762512
Peoria22956300
Champaign20530145
Sangamon18625234
McLean18041178
Tazewell16843282
Rock Island14861308
Kankakee14074209
Kendall1294192
LaSalle12459243
Macon10698198
DeKalb9812119
Vermilion9545132
Adams8407123
Williamson7397129
Whiteside7126171
Boone666472
Ogle607681
Grundy585275
Clinton575190
Coles566594
Knox5525141
Jackson500364
Henry492963
Livingston480185
Stephenson473381
Effingham472172
Woodford471776
Macoupin467581
Marion4459115
Franklin443774
Monroe435593
Jefferson4270120
Lee414152
Randolph412684
Fulton389555
Morgan386981
Logan385057
Montgomery370873
Bureau369682
Christian364473
Fayette316955
Perry315860
Iroquois299366
McDonough281947
Jersey268849
Douglas258335
Saline256154
Lawrence240425
Shelby229037
Union225240
Crawford211426
Bond203724
Cass198425
Jo Daviess180524
Warren179246
Pike178652
Clark178533
Ford177446
Wayne176852
Hancock175231
Carroll174536
Richland174140
White169326
Edgar168539
Washington163825
Moultrie160426
De Witt149824
Mason149745
Clay148043
Piatt147914
Mercer145633
Greene143233
Johnson142715
Wabash134612
Massac133440
Cumberland129119
Menard122912
Jasper115018
Marshall105818
Hamilton83115
Schuyler7435
Brown7036
Pulaski6837
Stark63423
Edwards56812
Henderson52514
Calhoun5162
Putnam4813
Scott4781
Alexander46711
Gallatin4584
Hardin38412
Pope3174
Out of IL10
Unassigned02354

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 8 p.m. ET)

Cases: 729716

Reported Deaths: 13418
CountyCasesDeaths
Marion998331740
Lake53638968
Allen40585676
St. Joseph35651550
Hamilton35569408
Elkhart28514442
Tippecanoe22386219
Vanderburgh22300397
Porter18725308
Johnson17933379
Hendricks17209315
Clark12951191
Madison12649339
Vigo12440246
LaPorte11890211
Monroe11883170
Delaware10676186
Howard9908216
Kosciusko9401117
Hancock8275141
Bartholomew8061155
Warrick7778155
Floyd7657178
Wayne7042199
Grant7041174
Boone6690101
Morgan6563139
Dubois6153117
Marshall6039111
Dearborn580478
Cass5803105
Henry5713103
Noble560383
Jackson501673
Shelby490796
Lawrence4531120
Harrison435472
Gibson435092
DeKalb427885
Clinton427153
Montgomery423888
Whitley395639
Huntington390680
Steuben387057
Miami381566
Knox371990
Jasper364947
Putnam359960
Wabash353679
Adams341254
Ripley339570
Jefferson330681
White313854
Daviess296799
Wells291481
Decatur284892
Fayette280462
Greene278585
Posey271433
LaGrange266170
Scott265653
Clay259747
Washington240632
Randolph240281
Spencer232131
Jennings229949
Starke216353
Fountain212246
Sullivan211542
Owen199256
Fulton195440
Jay194730
Carroll188520
Orange182954
Perry182837
Rush173125
Vermillion169243
Franklin168035
Tipton162845
Parke146216
Blackford134732
Pike133834
Pulaski116745
Newton107734
Brown102041
Crawford99714
Benton98614
Martin88615
Warren82015
Switzerland7898
Union71010
Ohio56811
Unassigned0415