In a 5-4 ruling, Supreme Court sides with religious groups in a dispute over Covid-19 restrictions in New York

In a 5-4 ruling, the US Supreme Court sided with religious organizations in a dispute over Covid-19 restrictions put in place by New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo limiting the number of people attending religious services.

Posted: Nov 26, 2020 10:12 AM

(CNN) -- In a 5-4 ruling, the US Supreme Court sided with religious organizations in a dispute over Covid-19 restrictions put in place by New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo limiting the number of people attending religious services.

The case is the latest pitting religious groups against city and state officials seeking to stop the spread of Covid-19, and it highlights the impact of Justice Amy Coney Barrett on the court. The decision comes as coronavirus cases surge across the country.

In the late-night decision, Barrett sided with her conservative colleagues in the dispute, while Chief Justice John Roberts joined the three liberal justices in dissent.

Last spring and summer, before the death of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, the court split 5-4 on similar cases out of California and Nevada, with Roberts and the liberals in the majority siding against houses of worship. Barrett was confirmed in October to take Ginsburg's seat.

Ruling says houses of worship face 'far more restrictive' regulations
The ruling, released just before midnight on Thanksgiving eve, contains several separate opinions and some unusually critical language.

In the main, unsigned opinion, the majority ruled in favor of the Roman Catholic Diocese of Brooklyn and Agudath Israel of America that argued that the restrictions violated the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment because the regulations treated the houses of worship more harshly than comparable secular facilities.

The majority said that the regulations are "far more restrictive than any Covid-related regulations that have previously come before the court, much tighter than those adopted by many other jurisdictions hard hit by the pandemic, and far more severe than has been shown to be required to prevent the spread of the virus" at the religious services in question.

The restrictions on attendance are divided up by geographic zones in areas classified as "red" or "orange" zones.

The Roman Catholic Diocese of Brooklyn issued a statement Thursday morning applauding the court's decision, saying that they are gratified and appreciate the court's recognition of a "clear First Amendment violation and urgent need for relief in this case."

"I have said from the beginning the restrictions imposed by Governor Cuomo were an overreach that did not take into account the size of our churches or the safety protocols that have kept parishioners safe," Reverend Nicholas DiMarzio, Bishop of Brooklyn, said in a statement.

In court papers, lawyers for Cuomo argued that the restrictions were necessary to help stop the spread of Covid-19 and that houses of worship weren't being treated differently than similar secular businesses. They also said that while the dispute was pending, Cuomo had already lifted any restrictions that applied to the organizations.

"Not only is there no evidence that the applicants have contributed to the spread of COVID-19 but there are many other less restrictive rules that could be adopted to minimize the risk to those attending religious services," the Court held.

"Members of this Court are not public health experts, and we should respect the judgment of those with special expertise and responsibility in this area," the court said. "But even in a pandemic, the Constitution cannot be put away and forgotten."

The court said that even though Cuomo had lifted some restrictions, the houses of worship "remain under a constant threat" because the restrictions could always be reinstated.

Lower courts had sided with Cuomo.

Lawyers for the diocese had told the justices in court papers that the "pandemic alone cannot justify overbroad, untailored closure orders of indefinite duration directed at all houses of worship, that in another time would plainly be found to violate the Constitution."

And lawyers for the Agudath Israel of America said that the governor has specifically targeted Orthodox Jews who have "violated his prior rules."

"The Governor's guilt-by-religious-association restrictions have made it impossible for Applicants and their members to exercise their religious faith," they argued.

6 opinions in the late-night ruling
In all, the late-night ruling consisted of six different opinions.

Justice Neil Gorsuch wrote his own concurrence -- joined by no other justice -- to explain his vote.

He said that other businesses such as bicycle repair shops, did not have similar restrictions.

"So, at least according to the Governor, it may be unsafe to go to church, but it is always fine to pick up another bottle of wine" or "shop for a new bike," Gorsuch wrote.

He was critical of the reasoning of a decision penned by Roberts in May rejecting a request from a church in California to block limitations on the number of people who could attend religious services during the pandemic.

Gorsuch said the court precedent Roberts cited in that decision "hardly supports cutting the Constitution loose during a pandemic."

For his part, Roberts said he was in dissent because while "it may well be that such restrictions violate the Free Exercise Clause," Cuomo had revised the restrictions after the religious organizations had filed their challenge.

"It is a significant matter to override determinations made by public health officials concerning what is necessary for public safety in the midst of a deadly pandemic," Roberts wrote, and said that the houses of worship could have returned to court if Cuomo had reversed himself.

But Roberts -- who often works to keep the court out of the political fray and divisive atmosphere that has dominated the other branches of government -- had stern words for Gorsuch's criticism of the dissenters' reasoning.

"They simply view the matter differently after careful study and analysis reflecting their best efforts to fulfill their responsibility under the Constitution," he said.

He also pointedly defended his own reasoning in the case from May.

Justice Stephen Breyer, joined by Justices Elena Kagan and Sonia Sotomayor, said that the regulations were designed to "fight the rapidly spreading -- and, in many cases, fatal -- COVID-19 virus," and that they allowed the governor to identity hot spots where the virus had spiked. Breyer noted the grisly statistics concerning the virus that has infected more than 12 million Americans and is currently surging. "The Constitution principally entrusts the safety and the health of the people to the politically accountable officials of the States," Breyer wrote.

The-CNN-Wire
™ & © 2020 Cable News Network, Inc., a WarnerMedia Company. All rights reserved.

Terre Haute
Clear
23° wxIcon
Hi: 37° Lo: 12°
Feels Like: 17°
Robinson
Clear
26° wxIcon
Hi: 37° Lo: 14°
Feels Like: 19°
Indianapolis/Eagle Creek
Clear
23° wxIcon
Hi: 33° Lo: 12°
Feels Like: 14°
Paris
Clear
25° wxIcon
Hi: 36° Lo: 10°
Feels Like: 17°
Mattoon/Charleston
Clear
23° wxIcon
Hi: 36° Lo: 12°
Feels Like: 12°
Terre Haute
Clear
23° wxIcon
Hi: 36° Lo: 12°
Feels Like: 17°
Terre Haute
Clear
23° wxIcon
Hi: 36° Lo: 11°
Feels Like: 17°
More sunshine today but cold
WTHI Planner
WTHI Temps
WTHI Radar

Latest Video

Image

Saturday: Mostly sunny and cold. High: 34°

Image

Riverton Parke Holds on to Beat North Central

Image

Greencastle Gets Back in the Win Column Against South Vermillion

Image

Lady Knights Drop a Heart Breaker in Overtime

Image

Northview Boys Roll Indian Creek

Image

Linton Brown County

Image

South Knox Vincennes Lincoln

Image

Northeast Dubois Vincennes Rivet

Image

North Knox Pike Central

Image

Bloomfield Eastern Greene

WTHI Events

 

Illinois Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 7 p.m. CT)

Cases: 1093375

Reported Deaths: 20534
CountyCasesDeaths
Cook4416579197
DuPage703241165
Will59269886
Lake54272903
Kane46750699
Winnebago26623414
Madison25015472
St. Clair22782439
McHenry22050253
Champaign15752104
Peoria15316252
Sangamon14767239
McLean13472170
Tazewell12191250
Rock Island12127306
Kankakee11631185
Kendall988481
LaSalle9704249
Macon8936182
Vermilion7707115
DeKalb761592
Adams7507125
Williamson6293117
Boone561778
Whiteside5403175
Clinton514586
Coles476185
Ogle467672
Knox4674146
Grundy447954
Effingham435970
Jackson428570
Henry408277
Marion4051113
Macoupin397596
Franklin390871
Randolph376773
Livingston375969
Monroe365171
Stephenson360177
Jefferson3521104
Woodford330768
Morgan330092
Logan314758
Montgomery312251
Lee312075
Bureau304184
Christian303476
Fayette295453
Perry275561
Iroquois261358
Fulton260149
Jersey227459
Lawrence220530
McDonough218151
Saline206854
Douglas203434
Union202432
Shelby201035
Crawford181934
Cass178531
Bond177424
Warren159644
Pike158348
Richland156246
Hancock153535
Wayne153543
Clark152133
Jo Daviess151324
Edgar148953
Washington148526
Carroll145733
Moultrie140528
Ford139951
White138231
Clay133340
Greene127443
Johnson124215
Wabash120414
Piatt118918
Mason118441
Mercer118130
De Witt118027
Cumberland111427
Massac105832
Jasper105715
Menard90710
Hamilton72917
Marshall69315
Schuyler64616
Pulaski6223
Brown61911
Stark49720
Edwards4769
Henderson46516
Calhoun4494
Alexander4047
Scott3971
Gallatin3934
Putnam3552
Hardin3098
Pope2553
Unassigned1230
Out of IL320

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 8 p.m. ET)

Cases: 605426

Reported Deaths: 9642
CountyCasesDeaths
Marion836221331
Lake45189680
Allen32646547
Hamilton29240315
St. Joseph27260380
Elkhart24354344
Vanderburgh19292248
Tippecanoe17905133
Johnson14974293
Porter14707168
Hendricks14295248
Madison10909220
Vigo10688179
Clark10581139
Monroe9338110
Delaware9089134
LaPorte9007162
Howard8177143
Kosciusko803182
Warrick668798
Hancock6639104
Bartholomew6443100
Floyd6377109
Wayne6106161
Grant5965115
Dubois554079
Boone549467
Morgan535595
Henry505564
Marshall502684
Cass482663
Dearborn476245
Noble471257
Jackson421947
Shelby413881
Lawrence389179
Clinton372043
Gibson369159
DeKalb345964
Harrison345644
Montgomery343354
Knox334339
Miami319844
Steuben313045
Whitley304526
Wabash301447
Adams299635
Ripley297545
Putnam294149
Huntington290659
Jasper288134
White272242
Daviess266774
Jefferson262538
Decatur246583
Fayette246348
Greene239262
Posey238128
Wells234050
LaGrange227662
Scott223439
Clay221832
Randolph212848
Jennings197736
Sullivan191133
Spencer190121
Washington183722
Fountain183127
Starke174843
Jay167022
Owen163637
Fulton163130
Orange157234
Carroll156415
Rush154418
Perry152727
Vermillion148634
Franklin147833
Tipton131832
Parke13038
Pike116226
Blackford110922
Pulaski96837
Newton90721
Brown87534
Benton86510
Crawford7929
Martin73013
Warren6777
Switzerland6575
Union6267
Ohio4867
Unassigned0375