Emmys: What the voters got right (and wrong)

From a surprise marriage proposal to an emotional speech by Betty White, these are the highlights from this year's Emmy Awards.

The Emmy Awards featured their share of surprises -- putting prognosticators on their heels, and spreading the wealth among a number of networks

Posted: Sep 18, 2018 8:36 AM
Updated: Sep 18, 2018 1:59 PM

(CNN) -- The Emmy Awards featured their share of surprises -- putting prognosticators on their heels, and spreading the wealth among a number of networks. There was also a welcome mix of old and new, which is one of the unique challenges that TV faces, from recognizing that much-talked-about new series to paying homage to a long-running show in its final year.

That process creates a degree of difficulty for TV awards that, in some respects, goes beyond what movies, music or theater face. So kudos to the Television Academy for what its members got right, and better luck next time on a few areas where, arguably, they got it wrong.

In the plus column:

Although you couldn't really go wrong with "Game of Thrones" or "The Handmaid's Tale," the academy seemed to send a message that at least for now, when it comes to the best-drama throne, anything else is going to have to wait its turn. And given the scope of the HBO series -- heading into its eagerly anticipated final season -- that's perhaps as it should be.

"The Americans" was never a huge hit ratings-wise, but it enjoyed a fiercely devoted following, and ended its run on an especially satisfying note -- never easy with a show this complicated. As a result, the twin victories for star Matthew Rhys and in drama writing felt especially well deserved.

"Godless." One could argue that "Godless" should have edged out "The Assassination of Gianni Versace" in the limited series category, but the supporting wins for Merritt Wever and Jeff Daniels were a solid consolation prize.

Credit voters, too, with looking past movie-star appeal -- always a factor at the Emmys when actors with those credentials are involved -- and choosing Darren Criss for "Versace," despite Benedict Cumberbatch's sizable shadow. Ditto, too, for honoring Regina King, who was easily the best thing about Netflix's "Seven Seconds."

Henry Winkler. Occasionally, a sentimental and popular choice can be the right one, and Winkler's first win -- after six nominations dating back to the 1970s -- for HBO's "Barry," coupled with his ebullient speech, were a terrific way to kick off the night.

In the "wish they'd gone in a different direction" dept....

"The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel" is a fine show, but its five-Emmy, near-sweep of the top comedy categories felt excessive, even with "Atlanta's" second season falling short of the first. Then again, with the benefit of hindsight chalk that up, in part, to the void left by perennial comedy champ "Veep," which sat out this year's festivities.

"Last Week Tonight" remains a splendid half-hour, but John Oliver's third consecutive Emmy came at the expense of fellow "The Daily Show" alum Stephen Colbert, whose "Late Show," both commercially and creatively, enjoyed a breakthrough year, becoming a vital nightly voice of satire since Donald Trump's inauguration. Beyond that, there's the simple difference between doing one half-hour show a week and churning out five episodes, which also merits more consideration, seemingly, then voters applied.

The Emmy-bashing Emmys. Finally, a word about the telecast itself, separate from the voting. Beyond its other drawbacks, hosts Michael Che and Colin Jost joked about the Emmys' low ratings, their lack of coolness (Jost gave a shout out to viewers at the "Silver Lining Senior Center"), and generally sniped at the entire awards process.

A degree of self-deprecating humor is always welcome, and it plays well in the room. But that's easier to laugh off when delivered from a position of strength, not the weakness of a show searching for its identity, coming off ratings lows the past two years.

The-CNN-Wire
™ & © 2018 Cable News Network, Inc., a Time Warner Company. All rights reserved.

Terre Haute
Clear
65° wxIcon
Hi: 89° Lo: 65°
Feels Like: 65°
Robinson
Clear
62° wxIcon
Hi: 89° Lo: 67°
Feels Like: 62°
Indianapolis
Clear
69° wxIcon
Hi: 89° Lo: 67°
Feels Like: 69°
Rockville
Clear
63° wxIcon
Hi: 91° Lo: 65°
Feels Like: 63°
Casey
Clear
68° wxIcon
Hi: 87° Lo: 69°
Feels Like: 68°
Brazil
Clear
65° wxIcon
Hi: 90° Lo: 65°
Feels Like: 65°
Marshall
Clear
65° wxIcon
Hi: 88° Lo: 64°
Feels Like: 65°
Clear and cool evening.
WTHI Planner
WTHI Temps
WTHI Radar

Latest Video

Image

Shakamak's Offense Propels the Lakers to the State Finals

Image

Aviators Sweep the Rex

Image

Domestic violence awareness

Image

Sunday Evening Forecast

Image

SCAM ALERT: Social media influencer ruse

Image

Business holds cooking class

Image

People gathered to protest circus

Image

The Storm Team explains hyperthermia and heat-related illnesses

Image

Railroad museum back on track

Image

Special Olympics wraps up

WTHI Events

 

Illinois Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 7 p.m. CT)

Cases: 1387217

Reported Deaths: 25469
CountyCasesDeaths
Cook55573410419
DuPage922971318
Will768611027
Lake682821009
Kane59372803
Winnebago34040500
Madison30888526
McHenry29160293
St. Clair28257519
Peoria23437339
Champaign21077153
Sangamon19066237
McLean18540187
Tazewell17207302
Rock Island15238328
Kankakee14529216
Kendall1327098
LaSalle12763249
Macon10980211
DeKalb10099121
Vermilion9988140
Adams8654126
Williamson7566134
Whiteside7195174
Boone682976
Ogle620483
Grundy598278
Clinton578791
Coles5759100
Knox5636152
Jackson509865
Henry507270
Livingston489591
Stephenson481385
Woodford481382
Macoupin478088
Effingham476372
Franklin454478
Marion4509117
Jefferson4417122
Monroe438094
Lee419453
Randolph416087
Fulton405159
Logan396063
Morgan392982
Christian383675
Montgomery379074
Bureau378183
Fayette321655
Perry319860
Iroquois313167
McDonough290051
Jersey271552
Douglas260536
Saline260157
Lawrence241127
Shelby232337
Union227140
Crawford214526
Bond208824
Cass203027
Ford188248
Clark183633
Warren183648
Jo Daviess182724
Pike181753
Wayne180653
Hancock179831
Carroll178037
Richland176740
Edgar176340
White170226
Washington164725
Moultrie162728
De Witt157129
Mason154145
Piatt152214
Clay149243
Mercer149234
Johnson147316
Greene145333
Massac135840
Wabash135512
Cumberland130019
Menard124812
Jasper116118
Marshall108219
Hamilton84215
Schuyler7797
Brown7266
Pulaski6997
Stark64824
Edwards57612
Henderson53014
Calhoun5282
Scott4881
Putnam4863
Alexander47311
Gallatin4684
Hardin39112
Pope3274
Out of IL40
Unassigned02419

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 8 p.m. ET)

Cases: 749097

Reported Deaths: 13745
CountyCasesDeaths
Marion1030271775
Lake554211006
Allen41613691
St. Joseph36933564
Hamilton36505416
Elkhart29347459
Tippecanoe22849225
Vanderburgh22540400
Porter19313325
Johnson18386387
Hendricks17583317
Clark13190193
Madison13111344
Vigo12602253
LaPorte12385221
Monroe12152175
Delaware10947197
Howard10250225
Kosciusko9609119
Hancock8541144
Bartholomew8158157
Warrick7854156
Floyd7763180
Grant7227179
Wayne7154201
Boone6911103
Morgan6735141
Dubois6211118
Marshall6205116
Cass5989108
Henry5893108
Dearborn588878
Noble579786
Jackson508374
Shelby500697
Lawrence4727121
Gibson444093
Harrison440473
Clinton439855
DeKalb438585
Montgomery433890
Whitley405642
Huntington402181
Steuben398659
Miami392568
Jasper386254
Knox375690
Putnam371860
Wabash360583
Ripley346470
Adams344955
Jefferson335685
White329753
Daviess3028100
Wells294881
Decatur289992
Greene286385
Fayette284664
Posey273735
LaGrange272872
Scott269855
Clay265448
Randolph244683
Washington244534
Jennings235149
Spencer234131
Starke227558
Fountain218347
Sullivan213943
Owen210858
Fulton201542
Jay200832
Carroll193420
Orange188055
Perry186937
Rush175626
Vermillion173544
Franklin170135
Tipton165746
Parke148916
Pike137934
Blackford136032
Pulaski120047
Newton112636
Brown103943
Crawford102316
Benton100814
Martin91415
Warren83515
Switzerland8098
Union72810
Ohio57811
Unassigned0421