The Associated Press fact-checked the first Indiana U.S. Senate debate Monday evening among Democratic incumbent Joe Donnelly and his challengers Republican Mike Braun and Libertarian Lucy Brenton. Donnelly, a moderate Democrat who has been in Congress since 2006, is considered one of the country’s most vulnerable incumbents in his race against Braun, a Republican who’s modeled his campaign as a political outsider and businessman after President Donald Trump.
Here’s a look at some of the claims during the debate, held at Purdue University Northwest’s Westville campus:
BRAUN: “I would never be for any replacement of the Affordable Care Act unless it covered pre-existing conditions.”
THE FACTS: Braun has suggested otherwise.
He has previously called for Congress to scrap the entire Affordable Care Act, which would wipe away protections that prohibit insurers from denying coverage or charging more in premiums to people with pre-existing conditions.
An estimated 1.1 million people under the age of 65, in Indiana have a pre-existing condition, according to a 2015 report from the nonpartisan Kaiser Family Foundation .
Last year, while Congress considered a repeal of the Affordable Care Act, Braun authored a newspaper article urging Congress to force a full repeal of the health care law. In that letter, he vowed to “take action and keep pushing for the full repeal of Obamacare” if elected to the U.S. Senate. As recently as June, Braun said on Twitter that he would work with Trump “to fully repeal and replace Obamacare with free-market solutions .” In August, Braun told Politico he supported a lawsuit filed by a group of Republican attorneys general that seeks to have the health law declared unconstitutional.
Last month, Braun told a Terre-Haute newspaper in an interview that pre-existing conditions “should be covered and I believe there should be no limits on what is covered when a person gets truly sick or hurt in an accident.”
DONNELLY: “I voted against Judge Kavanaugh because of concerns about his impartiality and concerns about his judicial temperament.”
THE FACTS: Donnelly’s public explanation for casting a vote against Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh has shifted since he first announced late last month that he would oppose Trump’s judicial nominee.
In a statement on Sept. 28, the day after Christine Blasey Ford publicly testified that she believes Kavanaugh sexually assaulted her as a teenager, Donnelly announced he wouldn’t support the nominee. He demanded an FBI investigation into her accusations and criticized Republicans for refusing to allow a more thorough review of the claims. He said Ford’s testimony was “disturbing and credible.”
“We have been unable to get all the information necessary regarding this nomination, despite my best efforts,” Donnelly said in the statement.
At the time, Donnelly did not cite the judge’s temperament as a reason to oppose Kavanaugh, who had raised his voice and accused Democrats of a “political hit” while defending himself before the Senate Judiciary Committee.
No sooner had Donnelly issued his statement on Sept. 28, than U.S. Sen. Jeff Flake of Arizona called for the FBI to conduct a weeklong investigation into the claims. Fellow Republicans relented, and the investigation was conducted by the FBI, rendering Donnelly’s original stated reason for deciding to vote against Kavanaugh moot.
Asked during Monday’s debate about the controversy surrounding the Supreme Court nomination, Donnelly made no mention of the sexual assault claims against Kavanaugh or the FBI investigation as a reason for his ‘no’ vote.
BRAUN: “I’m a job creator and a political outsider.”
THE FACTS: Braun owns a national auto parts distribution company, Meyer Distributing, based in Jasper, Indiana, that employs more than 850 people across the country and his net worth is somewhere between $37 million and $95 million. While Braun isn’t a lifelong politician he’s not a total outsider, either. He served as a representative in the Indiana statehouse from 2014 until late 2017, when he resigned from the seat to focus on his U.S. Senate campaign.
DONNELLY: “(Braun voted for) the largest tax increase in Indiana history.”
THE FACTS: Braun did vote for a GOP-backed package of tax and fee hikes in 2017. The package included a 10-cent hike per gallon in Indiana’s fuel tax.
Braun’s opponents have leveled this claim before, and the AP found the claim misleading in a Fact Check during a Republican primary debate in February .
An economist said the claim is misleading because it doesn’t take into account inflation.
“The most recent (tax increase) is always the largest because of inflation,” Purdue University economist Larry DeBoer told the AP at the time.
The state’s largest tax increase in history, when inflation is included, was likely approved in 1983 when sales, income and corporate taxes were increased to boost revenue during the recession, DeBoer said.
AP writer Brian Slodysko in Indianapolis contributed to this report.
Find AP Fact Checks at http://apne.ws/2kbx8bd
Follow @APFactCheck on Twitter: https://twitter.com/APFactCheck
- AP FACT CHECK: Indiana candidates make misleading claims
- AP FACT CHECK: Trump’s claims in his State of Union address
- AP FACT CHECK: Trump pitches wall as magic bullet for drugs
- Fact-checking Trump's immigration speech
- Popularity of dual credit and AP courses grows in Indiana
- Indiana congressional candidate campaigning from overseas
- Indiana GOP locked candidate out of database
- Fact check: Trump promotes fake Ronald Reagan quote about him
- Make sure to check out TableScapes this weekend at Indiana Theatre
- AP Explains: How retirement legislation impacts you