Republicans and Democrats tear new divides as Senate debates Covid-19 deal and states are reopening

President Biden criticized states such as Texas and Mississippi for lifting Covid-19 restrictions, saying that we are on the cusp of being able to change the nature of the disease and that "the last thing we need is Neanderthal thinking."

Posted: Mar 4, 2021 8:10 AM
Updated: Mar 4, 2021 8:10 AM

Much of the Republican Party -- despite the deaths of more than half a million Americans -- still acts as though the pandemic is more a platform for political grandstanding than the worst national crisis since World War II.

New ideological divides are being exposed with President Joe Biden's huge Covid-19 relief bill coming up in the Senate on Thursday. There's also a fresh rush by GOP governors in Texas, Mississippi and elsewhere to ditch precautions that eased a horrific post-holiday spike in infections -- mirroring a similar and ultimately disastrous opening at the urging of ex-President Donald Trump last summer.

These moves follow a weekend in which some governors -- and possible 2024 GOP presidential candidates, such as South Dakota's Kristi Noem and Florida's Ron DeSantis -- boasted to conservative activists about keeping their states open even while the worst of the virus was raging.

Not all Republican governors have adopted the conservative orthodoxy of mask skepticism and spurning scientific advice. Some, such as Maryland's Larry Hogan and Ohio's Mike DeWine, have won bipartisan praise for their strategies.

But the broader GOP's tendency to put political goals over the recommendations of government scientists, a holdover from the Trump era, is also evident as battle lines are drawn in Washington over the $1.9 trillion Covid-19 relief plan.

It is only right that Democrats should face principled Republican arguments on whether they are properly targeting the spending blitz or rewarding pet causes and on whether huge aid to states and cities is needed. And 10 Republicans did seek to make that case in their failed effort to get Biden to sign on to a $600 billion stimulus that the President judged underestimated the magnitude of the health and economic crisis.

But GOP leaders also have a problem. Biden's measure is surprisingly popular, so they need to slow it down and discredit its contents to extract some political gains and deprive the new President of a clean win.

So Sen. Ron Johnson, R-Wisconsin, taking a timeout from his conspiracy-fueled effort to absolve Trump supporters in the Capitol insurrection, is planning days of stunts that threaten to turn debate over the package -- with unemployment benefits for millions of Americans set to run out within days -- into a made-for-conservative-cable-TV farce.

"We're talking about $1.9 trillion ... a stack of one billion dollars that would extend halfway past the distance to the moon. And we want to do this in a matter of hours? I don't think that's right," Johnson said Wednesday.

The senator plans to force a full reading of the bill -- that will take 10 hours -- and stretch out debate with an array of procedural traps.

The opposition to the Covid-19 bill and the stampede to open states before science suggests it is safe are brewed in the same political vat as the effort by many Republicans to solidify the lie that Trump was cheated out of power.

Each drama reveals behavior forced on a party that has collectively decided that its most reliable path to power relies on its own radical, activist base and providing soundbites to conservative media rather than adopting policies that might appeal to a broader group of more mainstream Americans.

The big lie that the election was stolen will loom over the Senate Covid-19 debate. Senators will meet behind high iron fences and increased security because of new fears of violence by extremists incited by Trump's lies and the absurd QAnon conspiracy theory that he will be sworn in as president on March 4.

Biden pleads for patience

In the other corner from the Republican disrupters, Biden, who won the presidency largely on a vow to replace Trump's denial and neglect of the pandemic with organized, compassionate leadership, is pleading with senators to act fast.

He argues that the behemoth of a bill is packed with funding to get schools open, injections into arms and to tide over laid-off workers and small businesses until a sped-up inoculation drive can revive the economy.

"I'm not sure we've ever seen something that is needed as badly as the American Rescue Plan that was as broadly popular," Biden said on Wednesday after adjusting some aspects of the bill to appease moderate Democrats, to the dismay of progressives.

The President is also expressing disbelief that Republican governors are using his success in broadening vaccine supplies as an excuse to open up with the virus still rampant.

"The last thing we need is Neanderthal thinking," Biden said on Wednesday, reacting to Texas and Mississippi laying plans for 100% openings, amid fears that new viral variants could trigger a new tsunami of infection.

If the vaccines are as effective as everyone hopes -- and Biden says there will be enough for every American adult in just three months -- the country could be entering the political endgame of the pandemic.

There is a definite sense that each side is positioning for the post-Covid-19 reality. If things go back to normal this year, Biden will credit the relief package, his reliance on science and the use of government power to mount a vaccination drive as Democrats head into midterm elections next year.

Republicans, especially those facing primary races, have an incentive to brand the Covid-19 relief bill as a giveaway by big-spending socialists who want to curtail basic American freedoms with mask wearing and keeping restaurants closed.

Fauci: Opening now is 'inexplicable'

Federal health officials warn that Americans need to stay patient for just a few more months to allow vaccinations -- which hit a seven-day average of 2 million per day milestone on Wednesday -- to suffocate the virus.

"It just is inexplicable why you would want to pull back now," Dr. Anthony Fauci, the government's top infectious diseases specialist, said on CNN"s "Erin Burnett OutFront" on Wednesday.

"We have been through this scene before, months and months ago, we tried to open up the country and open up the economy when certain states didn't abide by the guidelines (and) we had rebounds that were very troublesome," he said.

But as has been the case for the entirety of the pandemic, scientific arguments don't satisfy pressures bearing down on Republican governors in red states and their own particular political ambitions.

Texas Republican Gov. Greg Abbott's declaration on Tuesday that increasing vaccinations and a fall in Covid-19 infections meant it was time to ditch mask mandates and reopen businesses with no restrictions caused consternation in the White House.

The politicization of the pandemic was underscored in Sen. John Cornyn's cutting reaction to Biden's anthropological rebuke of Abbott, saying the President should quit "preaching to my state about how to handle this Covid-19 virus."

"At some point, the government needs to quit making arbitrary rules that do not have any demonstrable connection with the public health," the Texas Republican said.

Masks, social distancing and avoiding crowded indoor venues such as restaurants and bars are scientifically proven to be some of the most effective measures in preventing the swift transmission of the virus.

In Texas on Wednesday, speculation was rife over Abbott's motivations. Critics wondered whether he was searching for a headline following his poor handling of the rare winter storm that blacked out much of the state recently. Political commentators noted that the governor is up for reelection next year and vulnerable to an even more right-wing primary challenger. And should Abbott decide to run for president in 2024, he might find himself up against fast openers Noem and DeSantis in the Republican primary.

Still, the governor appeared to step back from a confrontation with the White House. A spokeswoman stressed to CNN that while he had said it was time for Texans to decide their own responsible counter-Covid-19 precautions, he was in no way arguing that the pandemic was over.

"It is clear from the recoveries, the vaccinations, the reduced hospitalizations, and the safe practices that Texans are using, that state mandates are no longer needed," the governor's press secretary, Renae Eze, told CNN. "We must now do more to restore livelihoods and normalcy for Texans."

But the Republican governor of Mississippi, Tate Reeves, hit back hard at criticism of his own announcement.

"Given how long ago Mr. Biden was elected to the US Congress, he certainly should know how Neanderthals think," Reeves said, taking advantage of the President's low-blow rhetoric to return the shot himself.

"You cannot focus on data and science and making good decisions on those days when the numbers are going up and ignore the data and science on those days when the numbers are going down," Reeves said.

His comment, however, appeared to misunderstand the basic science of recommended steps to quell the pandemic. Cases came down because of masking and restrictions on large gatherings inside and in public, not despite them. And since the virus hasn't disappeared and sufficient people are not yet vaccinated to limit transmission, the fear is that as soon as normal life returns, so will a new wave of infections.

Terre Haute
Cloudy
52° wxIcon
Hi: 67° Lo: 51°
Feels Like: 52°
Robinson
Cloudy
51° wxIcon
Hi: 69° Lo: 51°
Feels Like: 51°
Indianapolis
Cloudy
52° wxIcon
Hi: 72° Lo: 53°
Feels Like: 52°
Rockville
Cloudy
51° wxIcon
Hi: 65° Lo: 51°
Feels Like: 51°
Casey
Partly Cloudy
50° wxIcon
Hi: 66° Lo: 51°
Feels Like: 50°
Brazil
Cloudy
52° wxIcon
Hi: 67° Lo: 51°
Feels Like: 52°
Marshall
Mostly Cloudy
52° wxIcon
Hi: 66° Lo: 50°
Feels Like: 52°
Rain, Breezy & Much Cooler
WTHI Planner
WTHI Temps
WTHI Radar

Latest Video

Image

Parke Heritage Fountain Central

Image

North Vermillion Wins a Close One Over Seeger

Image

Casey Dominates Marshall

Image

Vin Lincoln Jasper

Image

South Vermillion Cruises to Victory over Attica

Image

Linton South Putnam

Image

RP Covington

Image

Sullivan-West Vigo

Image

North Daviess-Springs Valley

Image

Vigo County man wins bricklayer battle in Illinois

WTHI Events

 

Illinois Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 7 p.m. CT)

Cases: 1663364

Reported Deaths: 27810
CountyCasesDeaths
Cook63054211157
DuPage1073121374
Will905601118
Lake794341074
Kane67913866
Winnebago40662558
Madison39811590
St. Clair36119591
McHenry34360321
Champaign26817195
Peoria26730368
Sangamon25584283
McLean22826216
Tazewell20506330
Rock Island18679358
Kankakee17763246
Kendall16074112
Macon15178250
LaSalle14943285
Vermilion14137198
Adams13055152
DeKalb12056133
Williamson11989174
Whiteside8228180
Jackson805794
Boone785683
Coles7823121
Ogle751087
Grundy730385
Franklin7267113
Knox7176169
Clinton7080102
Macoupin6877104
Marion6857143
Henry659076
Effingham654499
Jefferson6477142
Livingston593297
Stephenson576392
Woodford572692
Randolph551299
Christian530082
Monroe5229100
Fulton519274
Morgan502598
Logan491474
Montgomery486179
Lee476060
Bureau440789
Saline431769
Perry430274
Fayette428163
Iroquois417077
McDonough371160
Shelby341847
Jersey333953
Crawford329230
Lawrence327732
Douglas324037
Union304948
Wayne299161
Richland278257
White277733
Hancock271835
Cass264230
Clark264039
Pike262357
Clay256753
Bond254524
Edgar254549
Warren242265
Ford241858
Carroll235138
Moultrie227633
Johnson223531
Wabash216119
Jo Daviess214129
Massac213548
Mason211452
Washington211328
De Witt204130
Greene203940
Mercer201735
Piatt199814
Cumberland188226
Menard170913
Jasper160121
Marshall140721
Hamilton132922
Brown10589
Schuyler105510
Pulaski103311
Edwards102517
Stark80928
Gallatin7848
Alexander71012
Scott7106
Henderson69614
Calhoun6832
Hardin59216
Putnam5594
Pope5436
Unassigned1662433
Out of IL100

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 8 p.m. ET)

Cases: 994079

Reported Deaths: 16225
CountyCasesDeaths
Marion1340942097
Lake657221150
Allen57000791
Hamilton45877460
St. Joseph43856606
Elkhart35467502
Vanderburgh31922473
Tippecanoe27644256
Johnson24778440
Hendricks23603353
Porter22676362
Madison18488404
Clark18336248
Vigo17227300
Monroe15089197
LaPorte14957249
Delaware14916255
Howard14547286
Kosciusko12115147
Hancock11562175
Bartholomew11413179
Warrick11205188
Floyd10966214
Wayne10812247
Grant9850216
Morgan9346176
Boone8793115
Dubois8194129
Dearborn813092
Henry8098149
Noble7911105
Marshall7767134
Cass7451119
Lawrence7368168
Shelby7085114
Jackson689887
Gibson6468113
Harrison639691
Huntington628799
Knox6262105
DeKalb621796
Montgomery6166109
Miami584894
Putnam572177
Clinton564571
Whitley556355
Steuben548772
Wabash5229101
Jasper517675
Jefferson504095
Ripley491684
Adams471373
Daviess4586112
Scott432968
Greene420496
Wells418087
Clay417060
White413461
Decatur4104101
Fayette401286
Jennings382060
Posey373643
Washington351048
LaGrange350978
Randolph339399
Spencer335842
Fountain331058
Sullivan326352
Starke309968
Owen309369
Fulton303166
Orange289762
Jay277144
Perry263552
Franklin261642
Carroll257632
Rush256732
Vermillion253554
Parke229126
Pike227143
Tipton224959
Blackford187040
Pulaski180354
Crawford157522
Newton155148
Benton150117
Brown142747
Martin137119
Switzerland133411
Warren119916
Union106315
Ohio83912
Unassigned0531