When did Barack Obama become a Republican?

Article Image

CNN's Harry Enten breaks down former President Barack Obama's popularity numbers and explains why taking aim at him is not a good idea for Democratic presidential candidates.

Posted: Aug 2, 2019 7:10 PM
Updated: Aug 2, 2019 7:10 PM

When did Barack Obama become a Republican?

I'm asking because, according to some folks on the debate stage in Detroit, support for policy positions like the public option, comprehensive immigration reform and trade agreements are now dismissed as "Republican talking points." The same applies to asking practical questions about how proposals would be passed or paid for. That's not only a sign of how far left Democrats are moving but also a warning about how liberals risk reinforcing Donald Trump's re-election playbook.

Of course, all this is absurd. Obama is the Democratic Party's most popular ex-President in living memory. Despite Republicans' relentless and often unhinged attacks on him as socialist and worse, it's now clear that he was a responsible center-left leader.

After inheriting the worst fiscal crisis since the Great Depression, Obama actually reduced the deficit in his second term and backed bipartisan reforms on stubborn issues like immigration. Many of his policy outreaches to Republicans were rebuffed, and it's because of the reflexive demonization of Obama that many Democrats today are saying that it's useless to reach out to Republicans. I understand their frustration. But still, the ability to work with Republicans is the third quality that a CNN poll shows Democrats want most in their next president, the first being an ability to defeat Donald Trump. And that requires more than a purely play-to-the-base strategy that ignores independent swing voters.

Let's not forget that passing Obamacare was a massive task. Obama proposed a public option as a more practical and popular alternative to the single-payer system that very few Democrats supported just a decade ago.

The fact that, in crafting Obamacare, Obama essentially adopted a Heritage Foundation proposal that was first implemented by Mitt Romney in Massachusetts did not stop Republicans from absurdly attacking it as a "government takeover of health care." And that's understandably fueled a lot of cynicism among Democrats who say they might as well now propose what they see as the real deal -- an actual government takeover of health care. Republicans' bad faith arguments have created the thing they feared.

But at a time when President Trump's Justice Department is actively arguing in court for a complete destruction of Obamacare that would leave millions without insurance, a Democratic proposal to take away people's private insurance threatens to blur some of the clear distinctions between the two parties on this core issue.

A public option is vastly more popular among Democrats and the general electorate than a play-to-the-base national health care takeover that would never pass Congress and prove staggeringly expensive to implement. Moreover, math isn't partisan: The idea that talking about the cost of a $30 trillion plan over 10 years means you're feeding into Republican talking points is nonsense.

The same logic applies to the current Democratic debate about immigration reform. It's become popular to propose decriminalizing illegal border crossings. But this only adds ballast to Trump's otherwise baseless argument that the Democrats support "open borders." There is just no way that this disincentivizes illegal border crossing. And the argument that decriminalizing illegal border crossings is the only way to stop family separations ignores the fact that current laws have been on the books for almost a century and the shameful increase in family separations is the direct result of a Trump administration policy which no other president has enforced with the same enthusiasm.

The right move is to back comprehensive immigration reform -- an earlier version of which every Democratic senator voted for, along with a handful of Republicans, including Lindsey Graham. It would increase border security while also finding a way to bring 11 million illegal immigrants out of the shadows, and it would permanently protect the Dreamers.

Crucially, the earlier proposal -- backed by President Obama -- also was not afraid to elevate the idea of assimilation, as well as the rule of law. But if a Democratic candidate today were to talk about the importance of immigrants learning English -- like Obama did -- so that our country has a common currency of communication, they'd run the risk of being excommunicated from the party. A belief in assimilation is not racist.

Likewise, we see that the Obama administration's support for the Trans-Pacific Partnership is increasingly demonized by Democrats, as well as by President Trump. While no trade bill is ever perfect in the particulars, its overarching goal was to contain Chinese expansionism by increasing the economic ties between America and other independent Asian nations.

The protectionist impulse now embraced by the far left and far right -- Bernie Sanders and Donald Trump --- is something close to the new establishment position while actually weakening America's influence around the world. We need to be strengthening multilateral institutions, not dismantling them, a stance which dovetails with autocrats' agendas.

These are just a few examples -- we could add Obama's support for charter schools at a time when candidates like Bernie Sanders and Bill de Blasio seek to dismantle them as some kind of fifth column designed to undermine public education rather than an effort to increase equality of opportunity. We see it in candidates' desire to say Obama's actions on climate change were woefully insufficient, as were his steps toward criminal justice reform. Good people can disagree in degrees, but the impulse to invalidate arguments as being un-Democratic is intolerant and unwise.

This castigation of many Obama-era policies as Republican talking points is especially ironic given that Republicans have abandoned many of the core policies that once united their party: free trade, family values and fiscal responsibility.

In the feedback loop of our politics, the fact that Donald Trump has intimidated his party with a populist mob mentality has emboldened some folks on the far left to feel that arguments about electability or reuniting the nation no longer matter.

This risks not just losing an election but compounding how dangerously off-center our politics have become. Successful presidents are committed to forming a more perfect union -- and therefore trying to unite rather than divide their party as well as the nation -- and that is a wise and winning course despite the aberrational electoral success of Donald Trump.

There is a dangerous temptation to believe that Donald Trump's breaking of democratic norms means the Democrats can move to the far left without electoral consequences in a country where self-identified conservatives still outnumber self-identified liberals by a substantial margin. Yes, the party needs to ensure that its base turns out in ways it did not in 2016 - but it also needs to win back the Obama voters who cast their ballots for Donald Trump.

A political party needs both wings to fly, and if the policies of Barack Obama -- a person who is still America's most admired political leader -- are being castigated as Republican talking points, that's a sign of how unmoored our political conversation has become from reality. That's vital to note, because beyond winning the nomination, the primary responsibility of the next president will be reuniting the nation.

Terre Haute
Clear
40° wxIcon
Hi: 66° Lo: 40°
Feels Like: 40°
Robinson
Clear
40° wxIcon
Hi: 65° Lo: 37°
Feels Like: 40°
Indianapolis
Clear
43° wxIcon
Hi: 64° Lo: 42°
Feels Like: 39°
Rockville
Clear
35° wxIcon
Hi: 64° Lo: 40°
Feels Like: 35°
Casey
Clear
48° wxIcon
Hi: 65° Lo: 40°
Feels Like: 45°
Brazil
Clear
40° wxIcon
Hi: 65° Lo: 39°
Feels Like: 40°
Marshall
Clear
40° wxIcon
Hi: 64° Lo: 39°
Feels Like: 40°
Turning Cooler
WTHI Planner
WTHI Temps
WTHI Radar

WTHI Events

 

Illinois Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 7 p.m. CT)

Confirmed Cases: 295720

Reported Deaths: 8916
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Cook1454625225
DuPage17786563
Lake17151488
Will14239382
Kane13285326
St. Clair6747192
Winnebago6300151
Madison5828143
Champaign481821
McHenry4653118
Peoria355552
McLean332523
Rock Island307177
Kankakee277677
Unassigned2562244
Sangamon247945
Kendall205425
Tazewell180927
LaSalle175857
Macon163645
DeKalb162239
Coles150831
Williamson142649
Jackson127625
Clinton122221
Adams119910
Boone115323
Randolph95811
Effingham8833
Vermilion8304
Whiteside78421
Ogle7486
Knox7043
Monroe69016
Grundy6876
Henry6795
Morgan67423
Bureau67112
Jefferson64138
Marion5732
Macoupin5677
Christian56511
Franklin5523
Stephenson5486
Union52424
McDonough49015
Logan4691
Crawford4664
Fayette4376
Woodford4327
Livingston4086
Shelby4084
Cass40411
Jersey39817
Lee3941
Montgomery38913
Iroquois36819
Saline3624
Perry35815
Bond3426
Warren3342
Douglas3187
Wayne3005
Jo Daviess2752
Lawrence2633
Carroll2386
Greene23513
Hancock2283
Moultrie2224
Richland2206
Cumberland2195
Washington2191
Jasper21210
Fulton1900
Clark1833
Pulaski1831
White1760
Johnson1630
Wabash1623
Mason1611
Clay1590
Piatt1430
Mercer1415
Pike1391
De Witt1292
Menard1281
Massac1172
Edgar1168
Marshall1110
Ford1085
Alexander851
Scott800
Gallatin752
Hamilton742
Henderson710
Brown690
Edwards680
Putnam630
Calhoun620
Stark562
Schuyler500
Hardin390
Pope301
Out of IL30

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 8 p.m. ET)

Confirmed Cases: 120019

Reported Deaths: 3632
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Marion21671768
Lake10772325
St. Joseph6763116
Elkhart6755112
Allen6411206
Hamilton4997110
Vanderburgh390632
Hendricks2789125
Monroe270837
Tippecanoe265213
Johnson2383126
Clark229357
Porter223347
Delaware204162
Cass19619
Vigo190628
Madison173575
LaPorte153241
Warrick142847
Floyd142064
Howard134164
Kosciusko130117
Bartholomew120357
Marshall102924
Dubois102119
Boone100346
Grant97237
Hancock95143
Noble93532
Henry83027
Wayne78115
Jackson77910
Morgan73940
Shelby68929
Daviess68429
Dearborn67928
LaGrange65111
Clinton64414
Harrison60124
Putnam59211
Gibson5606
Knox54410
Lawrence53029
Montgomery51222
DeKalb50111
White49114
Decatur46339
Miami4394
Greene43236
Fayette42314
Jasper4032
Steuben3997
Scott39611
Posey3712
Sullivan33912
Jennings31812
Clay3155
Franklin31525
Ripley3098
Whitley2956
Orange28924
Adams2833
Carroll28313
Wabash2758
Starke2747
Wells2734
Washington2702
Spencer2693
Huntington2543
Jefferson2543
Fulton2472
Tipton23323
Randolph2308
Perry22613
Jay1931
Pike1771
Newton17511
Owen1721
Martin1690
Rush1584
Vermillion1330
Fountain1302
Blackford1243
Pulaski1141
Crawford1110
Parke1112
Brown1023
Benton870
Ohio797
Union790
Switzerland680
Warren411
Unassigned0227