Smearing Soros to stoke hate: You too, Facebook?

The calls came fast, all with the same question: Is it true you are funded by George Soros? I was dismayed. ...

Posted: Nov 21, 2018 9:04 AM
Updated: Nov 21, 2018 9:04 AM

The calls came fast, all with the same question: Is it true you are funded by George Soros? I was dismayed. I run a national racial justice organization, and a story had just broken that named us in a controversy. The New York Times reported that Facebook had sought to deflect blame for its role in empowering far right hate speech by, in fact, employing a right-wing media company to spread a soft, sanitized version of that same hate speech. And instead of holding Facebook accountable for that, these reporters just wanted me to confirm whether Soros was a funder.

According to the Times report, Facebook had been trying to convince reporters that our campaign to push the social media giant into better behavior was secretly part of a coordinated effort undertaken by organizations funded by Soros. This is a thinly veiled version of a more sinister, increasingly pervasive theory: that organizations fighting for social change are secretly controlled by Soros and some master Jewish plot to take over America.

Belief, religion and spirituality

Business figures

Companies

Conservatism

Discrimination

Facebook

George Soros

Nationalism

Racism and racial discrimination

Religious discrimination

Right-wing extremism

Societal issues

Society

White supremacy and neo-Nazism

White nationalists have been targeting Soros, an investor and philanthropist, for some time. Knowing that their conspiracy theories are echoing around the right-wing blogosphere is one thing. But hearing that those theories are being advanced by a company with the eyes of over 2 billion users is quite another.

While Facebook has denied paying a media company to write news stories or spread information, if you trust The New York Times reporting, as I do, then Facebook allegedly used an outside company to point the finger at Soros. Why? Because the goal of these attacks is the revival of an age-old strategy of using anti-Jewish attacks to discredit all progressive social movements, including ours.

In some ways, the report of Facebook's tactics is the most powerful proof yet that in the three years since Donald Trump announced his candidacy, white supremacy views and anti-Jewish conspiracy theories have moved into the mainstream. This fall, we saw the inevitable results of their success: violence. It started with a pipe bomb sent by a Trump fanatic to Soros himself and ended with the most deadly assault against Jewish people in American history in Pittsburgh.

Yet violence is only the most extreme and obvious effect. If we fail to understand how white nationalist and right-wing attacks on Soros fit together with their perennial attacks on communities of color, we are missing their full strategy. We are also missing the threat it poses.

The idea that my organization, for instance, is focused on what Soros is giving us, rather than on what conservatives are trying to take away -- our vote, our health care, our liberty, our job protections -- is a laughable distraction. But the idea that my organization is a pawn in someone else's game, rather than the self-determined and black-led force that we are, is dangerously undermining.

That our concerns and strategies are really a front for Soros' concerns and strategies diminishes not only our cause of challenging institutional racism, but also our standing and power in society. Soros is far from our only or largest funder. Undermining black people's power in this way benefits white nationalists obviously, but it also helps all those organizations whose decisions adversely affect black people but who want to avoid the accountability that our work demands -- organizations like Facebook.

It is just as true for all those whose activism and advocacy have been implicated in the attacks on Soros: immigrants, Muslims, feminists, LGBT people, Arabs and others. For instance, the same right-wing media claims about Soros pulling all the strings were made about women protesting then-nominee Kavanaugh, in order to dismiss their concerns without having to address them.

And if you think the fear of black people and the fear of Jewish people are not being used in tandem, just watch the ad that closed out the election for the National Republican Congressional Committee, the campaigning arm of the Republican Party. The ad starts with Colin Kaepernick and ends with George Soros standing over a pile of money.

Quite simply, white nationalists and some on the right do not want anyone who is not like them to exist in their reality. They especially do not want progressive social movements to become more powerful.

The conservative political establishment amplifying anti-Jewish conspiracies to win elections is no surprise -- they have caved in to every opportunistic obsession of the far right. But they still deserve shame for doing so, and social media companies, like Facebook, that shrilly insist on their own independence from that conservative agenda must fully renounce these conspiracies -- not willfully promote them.

They need to acknowledge that these anti-Jewish attacks, in addition to their immediate threat to Jewish people, are an attempt to disempower a much wider set of people whom we all depend on to advance democracy, equity and justice in American society.

Terre Haute
Overcast
30° wxIcon
Hi: 37° Lo: 24°
Feels Like: 19°
Robinson
Overcast
30° wxIcon
Hi: 35° Lo: 22°
Feels Like: 20°
Indianapolis
Overcast
29° wxIcon
Hi: 32° Lo: 26°
Feels Like: 16°
Rockville
Overcast
28° wxIcon
Hi: 35° Lo: 23°
Feels Like: 15°
Casey
Overcast
29° wxIcon
Hi: 33° Lo: 22°
Feels Like: 18°
Brazil
Overcast
30° wxIcon
Hi: 35° Lo: 23°
Feels Like: 19°
Marshall
Overcast
30° wxIcon
Hi: 36° Lo: 23°
Feels Like: 19°
WTHI Planner
WTHI Temps
WTHI Radar

WTHI Events

 

Illinois Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 7 p.m. CT)

Cases: 720114

Reported Deaths: 12882
CountyCasesDeaths
Cook3042206595
DuPage45087788
Will38684563
Lake37299631
Kane31767467
Winnebago18948262
Madison14379255
McHenry14269156
St. Clair13410259
Champaign1079858
Sangamon1015799
Peoria9147133
Kankakee8636103
Rock Island8612135
McLean848954
Tazewell6835104
Macon6517132
Kendall626947
LaSalle6108134
DeKalb499047
Adams473548
Vermilion391551
Boone390733
Whiteside3743115
Williamson361083
Clinton330861
Coles329859
Ogle285037
Knox280766
Grundy277618
Effingham277021
Henry270015
Jackson268536
Marion248551
Stephenson246635
Randolph226826
Livingston224527
Macoupin223218
Morgan220936
Bureau211643
Monroe207545
Franklin204825
Lee201034
Christian189443
Jefferson187859
Woodford175827
Fayette170931
Logan170113
Iroquois169326
McDonough158241
Fulton146012
Shelby137426
Douglas135416
Jersey127224
Union118228
Montgomery115519
Crawford112213
Saline111625
Perry110223
Warren109020
Jo Daviess107617
Carroll107024
Lawrence107011
Bond104810
Pike101427
Cass96423
Hancock95612
Wayne90833
Moultrie89810
Clay84020
Greene82831
Edgar80815
Clark79820
Piatt7835
Richland78019
Ford75222
Mercer74510
Mason72120
Johnson7136
Washington7002
Jasper64411
Cumberland61416
White6148
De Witt61317
Massac5993
Wabash5708
Menard4661
Pulaski4132
Marshall4066
Hamilton3873
Brown3224
Henderson2891
Schuyler2711
Stark2683
Alexander2562
Calhoun2470
Putnam2430
Scott2310
Edwards2263
Gallatin1913
Unassigned1850
Hardin1551
Pope1011
Out of IL100

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 8 p.m. ET)

Cases: 333312

Reported Deaths: 5685
CountyCasesDeaths
Marion45371865
Lake28722469
Allen19325304
Elkhart17945235
St. Joseph17599237
Hamilton14061171
Vanderburgh10280127
Tippecanoe920230
Porter873389
Johnson6973170
Hendricks6674158
Vigo637392
Monroe560850
Madison5410122
Clark540478
Delaware5184103
LaPorte492897
Kosciusko480741
Howard379478
Bartholomew347365
Warrick343073
Wayne340985
Floyd334978
Marshall317946
Cass307931
Grant295450
Hancock286957
Noble269347
Henry262837
Boone261955
Dubois249632
Dearborn238231
Jackson235534
Morgan228743
Gibson201229
Shelby199859
Knox196621
DeKalb190234
Clinton189222
Lawrence187949
Wabash181122
Miami176817
Adams176223
Daviess165845
Fayette157634
Steuben156415
Jasper155913
Montgomery154629
Harrison154124
Ripley151521
LaGrange150631
Whitley146815
Huntington140210
Decatur137144
Putnam134828
White134823
Wells134630
Clay132724
Randolph132622
Jefferson131316
Posey127718
Scott118921
Greene109053
Sullivan105016
Jay104414
Jennings97814
Starke96624
Spencer9078
Fulton88619
Perry86421
Fountain8608
Washington8387
Franklin75727
Carroll73713
Orange71828
Vermillion6867
Owen6598
Tipton62727
Parke6226
Rush5918
Newton58812
Blackford57312
Pike54020
Pulaski44215
Benton3843
Martin3826
Brown3705
Crawford3221
Union2862
Switzerland2725
Warren2653
Ohio2437
Unassigned0267