Pentagon rejects border troop request from DHS

The Pentagon rejected a Homeland Security request that US military troops perform emergency law enforcement functions to safeguard Customs and Border Protection personnel at the border to counter a group of Central American migrants walking to the US border to request asylum.

Posted: Nov 4, 2018 5:13 PM
Updated: Nov 4, 2018 5:18 PM

When the Trump administration first asked the Pentagon to send troops to the southern border, the administration wanted the troops to take on duties that Department of Defense officials viewed as law enforcement functions, CNN has learned.

The Pentagon said no.

According to two defense official familiar with the request, the Department of Homeland Security asked that the Pentagon provide a reserve force that could be called upon to provide "crowd and traffic control" and safeguard Customs and Border Protection personnel at the border to counter a group of Central American migrants walking to the US border to request asylum.

The Pentagon rejected the request on October 26, according to one of the officials, even as it signed off on providing DHS with air and logistics support, medical personnel and engineers.

The request was turned down because the Department of Defense felt that active duty troops do not have the authority to conduct that type of mission unless they are granted additional authorities by the President.

Defense officials have repeatedly emphasized the troops at the border are there to support civil authorities and that they are not expected to come into any contact with migrants.

Despite multiple defense officials characterizing those activities as relating to law enforcement actions, a DHS official disagreed that such functions constituted law enforcement.

"While DHS has discussed the need for potential assistance with force protection of CBP personnel, calling this line of support 'law enforcement activities' would be factually inaccurate," the DHS official said.

'Quickly and for a long time'

Active duty US troops are barred from domestic law enforcement unless there is an emergency, but President Donald Trump has repeatedly raised the prospect of having troops enforce the border as he campaigns hard on the dangers of immigration in the final days before the midterm elections.

At a White House speech on Thursday, the President suggested that troops should fire on migrants if they throw rocks, saying that rocks should be considered rifles and comparing the group of about 3,000 men, women and children to an "invasion."

On Friday, Trump tried to walk back those comments, telling reporters that "if our soldiers," or Border Patrol or Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers "are going to be hit in the face with rocks, we're going to arrest those people. That doesn't mean shoot them. But we're going to arrest those people quickly and for a long time."

The defense officials described the force DHS requested as something that would only be used if CPB personnel were overwhelmed by the situation on the border.

Even so, the Pentagon rejected the request for the reserve "protection" force, while it simultaneously approved all of DHS' other requests for support with Secretary of Defense James Mattis' approval. It's not clear if Mattis weighed in on the decision to reject the request for troops to perform law enforcement functions.

The first defense official said that in its response to DHS, the Defense Department said that if Homeland Security officials still want the reserve force of US troops, they should ask the White House to formally grant the Pentagon the authorities to perform those additional functions.

Customs and Border Protection declined to comment.

Homeland Security Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen, speaking to Fox News last week, said DHS had asked for air, engineering, logistics and planning support, as well as vehicle barriers and "ways in which we can protect my officers and agents, as well as the ports of entry themselves."

The Posse Comitatus law forbids the US military from enforcing domestic laws, unless there's no other choice. Military analysts say Trump can easily use the National Guard, US Marshals or personnel from Immigration and Customs Enforcement to back up border officers if need be.

Costs of the operation

More than 8,000 active duty troops could be deployed troops to the southwest border, more than he has serving in some of the world's most contentious combat zones, but they are there solely to support Homeland Security officials as they prepare for the migrants' arrival.

The troops will join over 2,000 National Guardsmen who are already at the border, meaning upwards of 10,000 American forces will be mobilized to stop Central American migrants that are still some hundreds of miles away from the border and weeks away from arriving in the US

Senior military officers have defended the deployment on national security grounds, but the mission -- dubbed Operation Faithful Patriot -- has been met with scathing criticism from many former military officials.

Retired Gen. Martin Dempsey, who served as the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff from 2011 to 2015, tweeted Friday that "our men and women in uniform are better trained, better equipped, and better led so they meet any threat with confidence. A wasteful deployment of over-stretched soldiers and Marines would be made much worse if they use force disproportional to the threat they face. They won't."

The Pentagon has yet to determine the cost of the operation, nor has it identified the account where the funding would come from. But the Center for Strategic and Budgetary Assessments estimates that the cost of placing active duty troops on the border could range from $42 million 110 million.

CSBA says that on the high end, the deployment would cost $143 per troop per day for operating and maintenance costs and $112 per troop per day on the low end. CSBA also estimates that the use of military aircraft in this deployment would cost about $136,645 per day.

With the mission currently set for November 5 through December 15, for a total of 41 days, the cost of deploying 8,000 troops and air support ranges from approximately $42 million to $55 million, according to the CSBA estimate.

Trump has said the total number of troops could climb as high as 15,000, which CSBA calculates the price tag to be at approximately $90 million to $110 million.

On Thursday, Trump claimed the military is putting up thousands of tents to hold migrants, but officials said there are no plans as of now to build tents. The officials said that while there had been informal talks between the Department of Defense and DHS about having the military build tent facilities to house detained migrants, tents were never part of the formal request for assistance submitted by DHS and approved by Secretary of Defense Jim Mattis. One official says that DHS was informally discouraged from making the request by the defense department.

CLARIFICATION: This story has been updated to make clear that the Department of Defense officials viewed the request as a law enforcement role. The Department of Homeland Security disputes that characterization, and the story has been updated with DHS comment.

Terre Haute
Clear
34° wxIcon
Hi: 50° Lo: 31°
Feels Like: 34°
Robinson
Clear
32° wxIcon
Hi: 49° Lo: 30°
Feels Like: 32°
Indianapolis
Clear
37° wxIcon
Hi: 48° Lo: 30°
Feels Like: 32°
Rockville
Clear
30° wxIcon
Hi: 49° Lo: 30°
Feels Like: 30°
Casey
Clear
36° wxIcon
Hi: 48° Lo: 31°
Feels Like: 31°
Brazil
Clear
34° wxIcon
Hi: 50° Lo: 31°
Feels Like: 34°
Marshall
Clear
34° wxIcon
Hi: 51° Lo: 30°
Feels Like: 34°
Sunny, Breezy Weekend
WTHI Planner
WTHI Temps
WTHI Radar

Latest Video

Image

North Central-Perry Central

Image

North Knox-Evansville Mater Dei

Image

Linton-North Posey

Image

Sullivan-Vincennes Lincoln

Image

Washington-Edgewood

Image

TH South-Cathedral

Image

Progress is moving along with the new THPD headquarters

Image

Terre Haute Fire Department welcomes eight new firefighters

Image

Knox County will begin enforcing Governor Holcomb's mask mandate

Image

People love to get into the spirit of Halloween, especially big cats

WTHI Events

 

Illinois Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 7 p.m. CT)

Confirmed Cases: 400159

Reported Deaths: 9945
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Cook1836495463
DuPage24240617
Lake21608518
Will19516434
Kane17738351
Winnebago10930185
St. Clair8173223
Madison7440157
McHenry6815121
Champaign646228
Peoria483077
Unassigned4770270
McLean432437
Sangamon432264
Rock Island426395
Kankakee358781
Macon344555
Kendall286930
Tazewell285358
LaSalle258467
DeKalb252443
Adams207123
Coles205840
Boone199825
Williamson197961
Clinton185631
Vermilion183011
Whiteside164630
Jackson161126
Knox138221
Randolph133815
Ogle13178
Effingham12664
Marion114723
Stephenson11299
Franklin105910
Grundy10477
Monroe100030
Morgan99925
Bureau95517
Jefferson93952
Henry8697
Christian86830
Macoupin84311
Union80225
McDonough79921
Lee7872
Douglas7429
Shelby73212
Fayette71924
Livingston70711
Woodford69215
Crawford6686
Montgomery65616
Logan6224
Saline6139
Fulton5901
Jo Daviess5479
Warren5419
Iroquois52719
Bond5259
Wayne51915
Jersey48221
Perry47816
Cass47011
Carroll45712
Moultrie4536
Pike4067
Johnson3850
Lawrence3558
Mason3425
Richland34218
Washington3322
Hancock3314
Clay33014
Clark31718
Greene31615
Cumberland3116
Mercer2996
White2794
De Witt2756
Jasper27510
Piatt2731
Pulaski2461
Wabash2436
Ford21115
Menard1881
Marshall1703
Edgar16511
Massac1612
Alexander1451
Hamilton1392
Henderson1320
Brown1220
Edwards1120
Gallatin1122
Scott1120
Putnam980
Schuyler981
Stark943
Calhoun660
Hardin560
Pope431
Out of IL10

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 8 p.m. ET)

Confirmed Cases: 172730

Reported Deaths: 4260
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Marion26807796
Lake15074371
St. Joseph10092174
Elkhart9783146
Allen9123235
Hamilton6697120
Vanderburgh640572
Tippecanoe424616
Porter372351
Hendricks3532139
Monroe345038
Johnson3438132
Delaware326378
Clark318865
Vigo293042
Madison270398
LaPorte248867
Cass234426
Kosciusko219529
Warrick212166
Floyd193369
Howard176267
Wayne156933
Dubois155727
Marshall154930
Bartholomew153259
Grant141240
Henry140530
Boone134850
Hancock130244
Noble129335
Jackson125420
Dearborn109728
Lawrence104238
Morgan103040
Gibson98212
Clinton97816
Daviess96036
Shelby95737
Knox89210
LaGrange85115
Fayette84922
Harrison83524
DeKalb82413
Posey8058
Putnam80017
Jasper7395
Miami7205
Steuben7059
Montgomery66622
White65816
Adams6337
Greene60838
Scott57916
Decatur56239
Whitley5216
Ripley5178
Wabash5079
Wells50412
Huntington4985
Clay4927
Starke4929
Sullivan48114
Spencer4436
Randolph43911
Orange43625
Perry42114
Jefferson4165
Fulton4159
Washington4143
Jennings40213
Franklin39625
Jay3816
Pike37018
Carroll36413
Fountain3643
Tipton29423
Vermillion2911
Rush2734
Parke2724
Blackford2555
Newton24411
Owen2251
Martin2070
Pulaski1874
Crawford1691
Brown1523
Ohio1457
Union1280
Benton1160
Switzerland1070
Warren1021
Unassigned0236