STREAMING NOW: Watch Now

The White House could tweet about cases besides Mollie Tibbetts

The man arrested in the death of Mollie Tibbetts is an undocumented immigrant, but this is a single story -...

Posted: Aug 24, 2018 5:43 AM
Updated: Aug 24, 2018 5:43 AM

The man arrested in the death of Mollie Tibbetts is an undocumented immigrant, but this is a single story -- not a statistic -- although President Donald Trump and other Republican politicians would like to make it seem otherwise.

Tibbetts, an Iowa college student, went missing in July and a body believed to be hers was found on Tuesday. After the arrest of Christhian Bahena Rivera (who according to Immigrations and Customs Enforcement is an undocumented immigrant from Mexico) on first degree murder charges, Trump referred to Tibbetts' death (still not officially confirmed) and called the nation's immigration laws "a disgrace." The White House tweeted Tuesday: "For 34 days, investigators searched for 20-year-old Mollie Tibbetts. Yesterday, an illegal alien, now charged with first-degree murder, led police to the cornfield where her body was found. The Tibbetts family has been permanently separated. They are not alone."

Government and public administration

Government bodies and offices

Misc people

Mollie Tibbetts

US federal government

White House

Companies

Continents and regions

Crime, law enforcement and corrections

Crimes against persons

Criminal law

Criminal offenses

Deportation

Discrimination

Domestic violence

Donald Trump

Homicide

Immigration

Immigration, citizenship and displacement

International relations and national security

Internet and WWW

Law and legal system

Murder

North America

Political Figures - US

Social media

Societal issues

Society

Technology

The Americas

Twitter

Undocumented immigrants

United States

Violence in society

This tweet is part of a larger narrative that the White House has stoked, in which the issue of immigration policy -- specifically invoked in the same tweet by its reference to family separation -- becomes a code for selectively dehumanizing and criminalizing undocumented immigrants. The White House tweets about Mollie Tibbetts, but why not about other cases?

At both the Republican National Convention in 2016 and the State of the Union in 2018, Trump had the family members of those murdered by illegal immigrants (to whom he refers as "Angel Families") share their stories. Then, as now, his evident aim was to make a handful of stories seem like a statistical norm.

The truth is that any young woman like Mollie Tibbetts (or myself) has a much greater chance of dying at the hands of a husband or boyfriend of any type than meeting harm at the hands of an undocumented immigrant in the United States. However, the White House immediately politicized the killing via its Twitter account, highlighting that the man charged with murder in Tibbetts' death is an "illegal alien," language that Trump has used consistently to dehumanize undocumented immigrants and to insinuate, despite evidence that shows the opposite, that undocumented immigrants are more criminal than other populations.

When Chris Watts was charged with murder in the deaths of his wife and two daughters this month, that news was treated differently than the murder of Mollie Tibbets. The White House did not Tweet, for example, "American citizen murdered his wife." And in news reports, Watts was referred to as "Colorado husband" or "Colorado dad," the kind of language that is apparently reserved for white men who murder -- not undocumented immigrants. Despite protests from the Tibbetts' family, the Trump administration continues to use Tibbetts' murder for its political purposes.

The Tibbetts family has suffered an unspeakable loss. Tibbetts' aunt, Billie Jo Calderwood, told CNN "I don't want Mollie's memory to get lost amongst politics" and a friend, Breck Goodman, said, "I don't want her death to be used for more prejudice and for more discrimination, and I don't think she would want that, either."

The reaction to Tibbett's death also exposes fault lines about race and prejudice. Not only is the White House not tweeting about Chris Watts, the Trump administration (and to a lesser extent, some of the media) has been silent about cases involving non-white victims -- ranging from missing black girls in Washington DC to the death of Nabra Hassanen, a northern Virginia Muslim teen, allegedly also at the hands of a man who entered the country illegally. The political expediency of using one girl or woman's death over another says ugly things about where we are in America today.

Is an accused killer's immigration status relevant, and if so, how? News outlets like The Washington Post led with "undocumented immigrant" in the headline, although after receiving criticism on social media, the headline was changed to "suspected killer, in the US illegally." How do we square featuring the immigration status of one suspect in a case with a female victim with the reality that women in America between the ages of 18-24, like Tibbetts, are most likely to experience abuse from an intimate partner, and on average 2-3 women per day are murdered by intimate partners in the US. Indeed, if the President wanted to focus on data about how to keep women safe, he would invest in domestic violence prevention. Instead, his administration has refused to grant immigrant women fleeing domestic violence asylum.

Another inconvenient truth that Trump has overlooked is the number of undocumented women who experience violence at the hands of US citizens. When I was on assignment on the US-Mexico border with National Geographic in June, I visited the Casa de Misericordia, a domestic violence shelter in Laredo, Texas. Some 70% of the women who have stayed at the shelter during its 20 years of existence have been undocumented.

While there, I interviewed Vanessa (a pseudonym I'm using for her safety, at the request of the director of the shelter where I interviewed her), 33, an undocumented immigrant who was staying at the shelter with her daughters, ages 3, 2 and 7 months. She was afraid because her boyfriend, a US citizen, had threatened to deport her and keep the children. "I don't care if I get sent back, but not without my daughters," she said. In June 2018, the New York Times reported that fewer immigrants were reporting domestic abuse, providing as an example the story of an undocumented woman who feared that if she called the police, she would be separated from her children.

Mollie Tibbetts' murder -- like all forms of violence against women -- is tragic. However, it compounds the tragedy for Trump to use Tibbetts' story for his own political aims -- to paint undocumented immigrants as inherently criminal. Trump, who has been accused of sexual misconduct by 20 women including his ex-wife Ivana, knows from personal experience how likely women are to experience intimate partner violence -- but that data isn't politically useful to him.

Terre Haute
Clear
89° wxIcon
Hi: 90° Lo: 66°
Feels Like: 91°
Robinson
Clear
87° wxIcon
Hi: 89° Lo: 66°
Feels Like: 91°
Indianapolis
Clear
88° wxIcon
Hi: 91° Lo: 67°
Feels Like: 90°
Rockville
Clear
86° wxIcon
Hi: 90° Lo: 65°
Feels Like: 92°
Casey
Clear
87° wxIcon
Hi: 88° Lo: 69°
Feels Like: 91°
Brazil
Clear
89° wxIcon
Hi: 90° Lo: 66°
Feels Like: 91°
Marshall
Clear
89° wxIcon
Hi: 88° Lo: 65°
Feels Like: 91°
Hot and humid!
WTHI Planner
WTHI Temps
WTHI Radar

WTHI Events

 

Illinois Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 7 p.m. CT)

Cases: 1411821

Reported Deaths: 25842
CountyCasesDeaths
Cook56221610554
DuPage935681321
Will779031042
Lake690991026
Kane60025816
Winnebago34649524
Madison32279533
St. Clair29901526
McHenry29537299
Peoria23680346
Champaign21517158
Sangamon19549245
McLean18817194
Tazewell17454308
Rock Island15371329
Kankakee14735224
Kendall13467100
LaSalle12938254
Macon11156215
DeKalb10258122
Vermilion10203154
Adams9468128
Williamson8064138
Whiteside7242174
Boone692680
Ogle628584
Grundy605079
Clinton588993
Coles5855101
Knox5727157
Jackson541365
Henry515270
Macoupin495990
Livingston493993
Woodford491683
Stephenson487886
Franklin484078
Effingham481574
Marion4739117
Jefferson4646123
Monroe450194
Randolph429387
Lee423154
Morgan412192
Fulton409959
Logan406766
Christian393875
Bureau384787
Montgomery383874
Iroquois328468
Perry327961
Fayette325956
McDonough304751
Jersey277752
Saline269757
Douglas262936
Union247141
Lawrence244127
Shelby235638
Crawford217626
Bond212924
Cass209927
Carroll204837
Pike199053
Ford193350
Hancock192232
Clark189734
Wayne188053
Warren186350
Jo Daviess183524
Richland180040
Edgar179642
White178826
Washington168225
Moultrie167428
Mason163147
De Witt161029
Piatt155314
Johnson153616
Clay153443
Greene152634
Mercer151534
Wabash146412
Massac141840
Cumberland130919
Menard127912
Jasper116818
Marshall109919
Hamilton88516
Schuyler8107
Brown8076
Pulaski7377
Stark66025
Edwards62812
Calhoun5362
Henderson53414
Scott5031
Gallatin4964
Putnam4943
Alexander48911
Hardin39512
Pope3384
Unassigned532432
Out of IL20

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 8 p.m. ET)

Cases: 766351

Reported Deaths: 13965
CountyCasesDeaths
Marion1052671804
Lake568691028
Allen42858698
St. Joseph37286568
Hamilton37260426
Elkhart29729470
Tippecanoe23441230
Vanderburgh23153404
Porter19568327
Johnson18807391
Hendricks18059321
Madison13518345
Clark13502198
Vigo12817255
LaPorte12558224
Monroe12529178
Delaware11124198
Howard10654237
Kosciusko9751123
Hancock8734149
Bartholomew8256157
Warrick8053157
Floyd8005181
Grant7349181
Wayne7234201
Boone7173105
Morgan6904142
Marshall6329116
Dubois6270118
Cass6085111
Dearborn600078
Noble597890
Henry5944111
Jackson515677
Shelby509897
Lawrence4914127
Gibson461596
Montgomery457592
Clinton454555
DeKalb453685
Harrison452476
Whitley415345
Huntington414081
Steuben410260
Miami405073
Jasper400455
Knox388091
Putnam384662
Wabash368783
Adams352256
Ripley351071
Jefferson341586
White339354
Daviess3089100
Wells302781
Greene292985
Decatur291693
Fayette285864
Posey280935
Scott278758
LaGrange277172
Clay273148
Washington253537
Randolph247583
Jennings238649
Spencer237931
Fountain234850
Starke229959
Owen222259
Sullivan219543
Fulton207845
Jay202832
Carroll197122
Orange190956
Perry189739
Vermillion180044
Rush177327
Tipton172347
Franklin171935
Parke154816
Pike141434
Blackford137832
Pulaski123648
Newton123036
Benton109615
Brown105943
Crawford105516
Martin92515
Warren87715
Switzerland8328
Union73510
Ohio58311
Unassigned0428