Supreme Court shakeup looms as Kennedy retires

The retirement of Supreme Court Justice Anthony Kennedy gives President Trump the chance to shape the highest court in his image for a generation to come. CNN's Abby Phillip reports.

Posted: Jun 28, 2018 11:54 PM
Updated: Jun 28, 2018 11:56 PM

Supreme Court Justice Anthony Kennedy announced his retirement Wednesday, and almost immediately the US Senate was launched into the national spotlight as it's the legislative body that will formally confirm whoever the next justice will be.

Here's what you need to know:

When will the confirmation process happen?

Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell has repeatedly said a vote will happen this fall. They're not waiting until after the midterms, despite the fact that the Kentucky Republican waited for 2016 to end before holding a confirmation vote on the seat vacated by the late Justice Antonin Scalia.

Why won't he wait?

Republicans see this as an entirely different situation. This vacancy is happening in the middle of the President's first-term, not at the end of a President's second term.

"These aren't the final months of a second-term constitutionally lame duck presidency with a presidential election fast approaching," McConnell said on the floor Thursday morning.

"Not gonna happen," said Texas Sen. John Cornyn, the No. 2 Republican in the chamber. "We'll have the same President," so the comparison to the transition from Obama to Trump doesn't work, he added.

When pressed on how the Senate could look different because of the midterms, Cornyn pushed back. "Yes and the Earth could end tomorrow," he said. "It's not a good excuse for not doing our work."

Democrats are obviously livid about this, but, much to their chagrin, there's nothing they can do.

The math

The current breakdown in the Senate is 51 Republicans to 49 Democrats. With Arizona Republica Sen. John McCain out, that brings it down to 50-49, which means Republicans can't afford to lose a single vote.

If any Democrats decide to vote with them, only then could Republicans afford to start losing some of their own.

But what about a filibuster?

That doesn't matter anymore. During the Gorsuch confirmation, Republicans weren't getting enough Democrats to side with them and get the 60 votes needed to avoid a filibuster. So McConnell decided to go nuclear and change the rules so that Supreme Court nominees needed 50 votes.

It was a huge deal at the time -- and still is -- but it was also seen as a retaliatory move, since Democrats had done the same thing a few years earlier with other executive branch nominees.

Whom to watch

On the Republican side, all eyes are on moderates Sen. Lisa Murkowski of Alaska and Sen. Susan Collins of Maine. We've already seen the power they can have in derailing GOP efforts, like when they helped take down a major health care vote last year, with McCain at their side.

Murkowski and Collins both support abortion rights, so if Roe v. Wade becomes a big issue in this confirmation battle, that could turn the two of them off.

Collins said Wednesday it was her "preference" to nominate someone like Kennedy, who was a swing vote on the high court.

"One of the things I most admire about him is that he did not view cases through an ideological lens but rather based on the law, the merits and the Constitution," Murkowski said.

That brings us to another point: Like Collins said, many senators, especially Democrats, will be looking for a nominee who falls more in the middle in the ideological spectrum to replace Kennedy, since that is the role he played on the court as a key swing vote. Gorsuch was replacing Scalia, a conservative justice, so it wasn't such a big deal that Gorsuch was considered conservative. Picking a conservative to replace Kennedy could solidify the court as a right-leaning body for years to come.

Whom to watch, part 2

If Collins and Murkowski start to fade, all eyes will be on Democrats from red states who are up for re-election this year and facing enormous pressure back home. It could help them immensely for Trump to pick a more moderate nominee, but if he goes with a hardline conservative or a wild card, that would make it really tough for these Dems to sign on.

In the Gorsuch confirmation, three of these Democrats (Sens. Joe Manchin of West Virginia, Heidi Heitkamp of North Dakota, and Joe Donnelly of Indiana) supported Gorsuch, but there's no guarantee they'll back Trump's pick this time around.

Along with those three, it's also worth keeping an eye on seven other Democrats who are running for re-election in states that Trump won. They include:

  • Sen. Claire McCaskill of Missouri
  • Sen. Bill Nelson of Florida
  • Sen. Debbie Stabenow of Michigan
  • Sen. Bob Casey of Pennsylvania
  • Sen. Tammy Baldwin of Wisconsin
  • Sen. Sherrod Brown of Ohio
  • Sen. Jon Tester of Montana

Of this group, GOP aides have their eyes primarily on McCaskill and Nelson, both of whom are tied in exceedingly tight races.

Conservative groups spent millions on ads lobbying these senators to back Gorsuch last year, but only Manchin, Heitkamp and Donnelly ultimately backed him.

But, as we mentioned before, this is now a court swinging, court defining pick. So several aides say it won't necessarily be viewed through the same vein Gorsuch was, when it was a conservative filling a conservative seat. So the pressure wasn't nearly as high on these red state Democrats.

Terre Haute
Clear
73° wxIcon
Hi: 88° Lo: 68°
Feels Like: 73°
Robinson
Clear
71° wxIcon
Hi: 86° Lo: 66°
Feels Like: 71°
Indianapolis
Few Clouds
73° wxIcon
Hi: 87° Lo: 69°
Feels Like: 73°
Rockville
Clear
72° wxIcon
Hi: 87° Lo: 67°
Feels Like: 72°
Casey
Clear
71° wxIcon
Hi: 86° Lo: 65°
Feels Like: 71°
Brazil
Clear
73° wxIcon
Hi: 87° Lo: 67°
Feels Like: 73°
Marshall
Clear
73° wxIcon
Hi: 87° Lo: 66°
Feels Like: 73°
Mostly sunny with a low chance of storms tonight.
WTHI Planner
WTHI Temps
WTHI Radar

WTHI Events

 

Illinois Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 7 p.m. CT)

Confirmed Cases: 204023

Reported Deaths: 7932
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Cook1147244951
Lake13144450
DuPage12693525
Kane10100305
Will9692348
St. Clair4289162
Winnebago3835134
McHenry3335114
Madison296985
Kankakee185769
Rock Island183138
Peoria180737
Champaign173719
Kendall144323
Sangamon139135
Unassigned1381211
DeKalb97032
LaSalle91028
Boone76823
Jackson75520
McLean73015
Macon72123
Tazewell6539
Adams6077
Coles56421
Williamson4997
Randolph4977
Clinton45417
Ogle4295
Whiteside38417
Grundy3685
Morgan3539
Knox3441
Stephenson3406
Monroe33913
Union33923
Jefferson32020
Iroquois27613
Henry2741
Bureau2624
Vermilion2592
Cass25211
Franklin2221
Macoupin2223
Effingham2081
Warren1960
Perry1933
Lee1911
Logan1871
Montgomery1797
Marion1720
Woodford1713
McDonough14915
Christian1464
Jersey1432
Livingston1403
Jo Daviess1391
Saline1362
Douglas1353
Moultrie1030
Pulaski1011
Shelby942
Clark912
White800
Hancock761
Johnson760
Mercer764
Fayette733
Carroll724
Wayne722
Bond693
Greene690
Washington691
Piatt660
Cumberland613
Jasper617
Mason600
Menard600
Ford572
Lawrence550
Gallatin512
Wabash490
Massac430
Fulton420
De Witt390
Alexander370
Crawford350
Marshall350
Edgar340
Hamilton330
Clay320
Pike320
Scott320
Edwards240
Richland240
Henderson210
Hardin180
Schuyler180
Brown150
Putnam130
Calhoun120
Pope110
Stark70
Out of IL10

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 8 p.m. ET)

Confirmed Cases: 78632

Reported Deaths: 3113
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Marion16437734
Lake7952283
Elkhart505191
Allen4161164
St. Joseph376683
Hamilton3033104
Vanderburgh212215
Hendricks1978109
Johnson1819119
Cass18139
Porter141539
Clark135250
Tippecanoe129312
Madison106266
LaPorte96730
Howard94865
Kosciusko87812
Bartholomew86747
Floyd86150
Marshall80523
Monroe78432
Vigo77913
Delaware77752
Dubois72912
Noble71729
Boone71646
Hancock70239
Warrick61230
Jackson6075
Shelby57328
LaGrange57110
Grant53330
Dearborn52828
Morgan50135
Henry46720
Clinton4624
Wayne41010
White38411
Montgomery36721
Harrison36524
Lawrence35927
Decatur35332
Putnam3318
Daviess29620
Scott28110
Miami2792
Jasper2662
Greene25934
Franklin25116
Gibson2464
DeKalb2444
Jennings23312
Ripley2218
Steuben2173
Carroll2135
Fayette2097
Perry18913
Orange18824
Posey1840
Starke1817
Wabash1805
Wells1802
Fulton1752
Jefferson1752
Knox1711
Sullivan1631
Whitley1626
Tipton15516
Washington1531
Clay1505
Spencer1403
Randolph1345
Huntington1303
Adams1242
Newton12110
Owen1131
Rush1004
Jay970
Pulaski841
Brown762
Fountain762
Pike670
Blackford662
Benton640
Ohio636
Vermillion620
Switzerland590
Parke581
Martin530
Crawford500
Union420
Warren251
Unassigned0207