Lawsuit: Harvard ranks Asian-Americans lower on personality traits

A group that claims Harvard puts quotas on Asian-American applicants contends the university scores them higher than ...

Posted: Jun 16, 2018 5:19 AM
Updated: Jun 16, 2018 5:19 AM

A group that claims Harvard puts quotas on Asian-American applicants contends the university scores them higher than students of other races on academics and extracurricular activities but ranks them lowest in a "personal" category covering such traits as likability and "attractive to be with."

In a federal court filing Friday in Boston, lawyers for the student group also asserted that while Harvard has a bias against Asian-Americans, it shows a disproportionate preference for black and Hispanic applicants.

"What Harvard will not admit," Students for Fair Admissions said, "is that race is not only an important factor, it is the dominant consideration in admitting Hispanics and African-Americans. An Asian-American applicant with 25% chance of admission, for example, would have a 35% chance if he were white, 75% if he were Hispanic, and 95% chance if he were African-American."

Harvard counters that the statistical analyses on which the challengers rely are flawed in multiple ways and say that the percentage of Asian American students has gone up over the past decade.

Asian-American students now make up nearly 23% of admitted students. African-Americans constitute 15%, Latinos 12.2%. A category of all others, mainly white students, is 50%.

Harvard did not directly counter the personal-rating statistic but said in a Friday filing that the challengers' data analysis failed to include applicants such as athletes and children of parents who attended Harvard or of staff at the school. Harvard also submitted an expert report that said the challengers' personal ratings model did not sufficiently control for such factors as the personal essay, teacher recommendations.

The country's oldest institution of higher education broadly defended its longstanding effort for racial diversity as part of the education mission. It denies that it unlawfully sets quotas or engages in racial balancing. Admissions officers undertake a "whole-person evaluation" that includes academic performance, extracurriculars, personal qualities, talent, as well as socioeconomic background and race.

Friday's filings offered the fullest picture to date of the kinds of assertions and evidence to be presented in the case that began in 2014 and that ultimately could affect admissions policies and racial affirmative action nationwide. The challengers' goal is reversal of a 1978 Supreme Court landmark decision that first allowed racial affirmative action.

Trial likely in October

Both sides filed motions for summary judgment on Friday, even though US District Court Judge Allison Burroughs has signaled that she would not rule without a trial. She has set an October trial date.

"Harvard today engages in the same kind of discrimination and stereotyping that it used to justify quotas on Jewish applicants in the 1920's and 1930's," the challengers assert, adding that if Harvard admitted students based only on their academic index, Asian-Americans would comprise over 50% of the admitted class.

Harvard, which draws 40,000 applicants each year for 1,600 college spots, scores students (on a scale of 1 to 6, 1 being best) on five basic categories: academic, extracurricular, athletic, personal and overall. The school says that the overwhelming number of applicants have superior academic credentials and that other categories can take on greater weight.

For the class of 2019, for example, more than 8,000 had perfect grade point averages, 3,500 had perfect SAT math scores, and 2,700 had perfect SAT verbal scores.

University lawyers opened their arguments on Friday by suggesting the real motive of the challengers is not to protect the interests of Asian-Americans but rather represents "the latest salvo by ideological opponents of the consideration of race in university admissions."

The case of Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard was was initiated by Edward Blum, a conservative advocate who has long fought affirmative action that gives blacks and Hispanics a boost. In previous lawsuits, such as against the University of Texas, Blum enlisted white students as plaintiffs. This is the first effort using Asian-Americans and this first major case against a private university.

The Trump administration last year signaled its support for the challengers and is conducting its own administrative review of Harvard admissions.

Federal civil rights law bars discrimination based on race. When the Supreme Court first upheld affirmative action in the case forty years ago, it said race could be one factor among many in deciding who gets a place, to bolster campus diversity, but it forbade quotas.

Students for Fair Admissions asserted on Friday that Harvard conducted an internal investigation in 2013 that found its admissions system was biased against Asian-Americans but that it then "killed the investigation and buried the reports." Harvard responded that the analysis was incomplete and never reached any conclusion about discrimination.

Terre Haute
Cloudy
70° wxIcon
Hi: 74° Lo: 55°
Feels Like: 70°
Robinson
Cloudy
68° wxIcon
Hi: 75° Lo: 56°
Feels Like: 68°
Indianapolis
Mostly Cloudy
70° wxIcon
Hi: 72° Lo: 56°
Feels Like: 70°
Rockville
Partly Cloudy
70° wxIcon
Hi: 74° Lo: 54°
Feels Like: 70°
Casey
Cloudy
69° wxIcon
Hi: 73° Lo: 56°
Feels Like: 69°
Brazil
Mostly Cloudy
70° wxIcon
Hi: 74° Lo: 54°
Feels Like: 70°
Marshall
Cloudy
70° wxIcon
Hi: 73° Lo: 54°
Feels Like: 70°
Scattered Showers and Thundershowers
WTHI Planner
WTHI Temps
WTHI Radar

WTHI Events

 

Illinois Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 7 p.m. CT)

Cases: 1364919

Reported Deaths: 24770
CountyCasesDeaths
Cook54636010136
DuPage907311283
Will75665991
Lake67328990
Kane58479777
Winnebago33296475
Madison30549520
McHenry28644288
St. Clair27886514
Peoria23156316
Champaign20674145
Sangamon18807234
McLean18185180
Tazewell16973289
Rock Island15019318
Kankakee14212210
Kendall1307994
LaSalle12573243
Macon10774200
DeKalb9886119
Vermilion9677132
Adams8476123
Williamson7435130
Whiteside7166172
Boone671173
Ogle611881
Grundy589775
Clinton576190
Coles569096
Knox5567150
Jackson503164
Henry500367
Livingston483185
Stephenson476583
Woodford476076
Effingham473072
Macoupin470883
Marion4471115
Franklin445575
Monroe435693
Jefferson4298120
Lee417352
Randolph413384
Fulton394457
Morgan390482
Logan388559
Bureau372482
Montgomery372374
Christian367773
Fayette317755
Perry317660
Iroquois302566
McDonough286247
Jersey269150
Douglas258935
Saline256554
Lawrence240625
Shelby229937
Union225940
Crawford212126
Bond205424
Cass199325
Jo Daviess181524
Clark180233
Warren180046
Pike179252
Ford178947
Wayne177753
Hancock176132
Carroll175536
Richland175240
Edgar170540
White169826
Washington164525
Moultrie161128
De Witt151625
Mason151445
Piatt150014
Clay148143
Mercer147333
Johnson144415
Greene143933
Massac134640
Wabash134512
Cumberland129019
Menard123612
Jasper115118
Marshall107518
Hamilton83615
Schuyler7587
Brown7106
Pulaski6877
Stark63824
Edwards57112
Henderson52514
Calhoun5182
Putnam4843
Scott4791
Alexander46811
Gallatin4584
Hardin38612
Pope3224
Out of IL50
Unassigned02355

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 8 p.m. ET)

Cases: 734736

Reported Deaths: 13471
CountyCasesDeaths
Marion1005261750
Lake54085975
Allen40876680
St. Joseph36249552
Hamilton35783408
Elkhart28784442
Tippecanoe22449219
Vanderburgh22359397
Porter18894310
Johnson18053381
Hendricks17298315
Clark13026191
Madison12740339
Vigo12490248
LaPorte12040214
Monroe11936170
Delaware10738187
Howard9974218
Kosciusko9455117
Hancock8346142
Bartholomew8091156
Warrick7795155
Floyd7682178
Grant7090174
Wayne7067199
Boone6732101
Morgan6603139
Dubois6165117
Marshall6092112
Cass5864105
Dearborn582678
Henry5772105
Noble564484
Jackson503273
Shelby493896
Lawrence4580120
Gibson436592
Harrison436472
DeKalb430185
Clinton428353
Montgomery425589
Whitley397539
Huntington393580
Steuben390757
Miami383268
Knox372790
Jasper370848
Putnam362660
Wabash355080
Adams342555
Ripley340470
Jefferson331781
White316354
Daviess298299
Wells292081
Decatur285792
Fayette281862
Greene280485
Posey272033
LaGrange268370
Scott267354
Clay260947
Washington241932
Randolph241781
Spencer232631
Jennings230749
Starke218454
Fountain213646
Sullivan212242
Owen202556
Jay197230
Fulton195740
Carroll190120
Orange184354
Perry184237
Rush173725
Vermillion170044
Franklin168435
Tipton163145
Parke146716
Pike135334
Blackford135132
Pulaski117245
Newton108634
Brown102641
Crawford101415
Benton99014
Martin89515
Warren82415
Switzerland7938
Union71410
Ohio57111
Unassigned0417