Unfortunately, the Force may not be with you

With a blare of Imperial trumpets and the now-familiar march of words across the screen, "...

Posted: Dec 18, 2017 10:25 AM
Updated: Dec 18, 2017 10:25 AM

With a blare of Imperial trumpets and the now-familiar march of words across the screen, "Star Wars: The Last Jedi" blasted its way into theaters across the country this weekend.

While the jury is still out on where the film ranks in the "Star Wars" pantheon, there is no denying the mark this movie franchise has had on society. (Note: there are no spoilers here.)

The "Star Wars" movies have never really been about science or technology. They focus more on spiritual issues and the storyline of a family seemingly destined to guide the fate of the galaxy. But the films are in the genre of science fiction and that means that scientists like myself can't help asking whether the science and tech we see on the screen are even remotely possible.

Let's take a look at some of them.

Droids

Droids, short for androids, are one of the more plausible technologies in the "Star Wars" universe. Current robotic technology is used mostly in industrial applications (with significant consequences for our economy, although that is another story). However, in "Star Wars," robots are not just industrial drones. Starting with the iconic C-3PO and R2-D2, and now joined by the personable BB-8, these robots have personalities and capabilities that differ little from people.

Modern-day engineers have already achieved the ability for robots to do backflips and have made extraordinary advances in artificial intelligence.

Reality check: Yep, definitely going to happen.

Lightsabers

There is perhaps nothing more iconic in the "Star Wars" franchise than the lightsaber. Heroic Jedis cut their way through a swath of robots, Stormtroopers and the occasional Sith Lord in a dazzling display of colorful swordplay.

There has been much written on how the lightsaber might work, with some real attention to the required technology. From "The Phantom Menace," we can deduce that the Jedi's lightsaber must wield at least 20 megawatts of power, which is about the energy needed to run approximately 14,000 American households, all stored in a device small enough to be held in the human hand. There are no known energy sources with that kind of capability, except perhaps antimatter. Even nuclear power won't work.

By ignoring this energy problem, various technologies have been suggested for how a lightsaber might work, but most center on the possibility that they are plasmas with perhaps a ceramic core. Then there is the issue of why the immense heat of these plasmas do not char the hands of the Jedis. All in all, the lightsabers and the possible technical solutions raise more questions than they solve.

Reality check: Sorry, Luke, Han was right when he said ancient weapons are no match for a good blaster.

Faster than light travel

"Star Wars" began with a story about the conflict between a rebellious group and an empire that spans a galaxy. And to have a galactic empire means that you need to be able to travel great distances in a reasonable amount of time.

We can take our own Milky Way galaxy as a baseline. It has a diameter of 100,000 light-years, which means that it would take a beam of light 100,000 years to cross it, and half of that to fly from the center to the edge.

There are reasons to believe that the galactic center would not be hospitable to technological civilizations. This is because of the proximity of stars and the dangers of radiation from nearby supernovas. So maybe the Empire "only" spans a few tens of thousands of light-years.

But even that smaller volume is immense. Traversing these sort of distances in a reasonable time will take a new discovery, like the hyperdrive of "Star Wars." Nominally, this involves spaceships moving through alternate dimensions of space and time to get to their destination. Unfortunately, there is absolutely no evidence of dimensions of this kind, and they probably don't exist.

Reality check: Not very likely, even if you live as long as Yoda.

The Force

Even people who have never watched "Star Wars" have probably heard the phrase, "May the Force be with you." The Force is said to be an energy field that permeates the universe.

According to the "Star Wars" canon, people contain within their cells intelligent organisms called midi-chlorians. People with more midi-chlorians can harness the Force to perform superhuman feats, such as telekinesis (using the mind to manipulate objects) and being able to anticipate the intents and motions of a foe.

Setting aside the fact that there have never been reproducible reports of telekinesis, there are some real physics issues here. For instance, when an object is lifted by any familiar way -- say, when you or I pick up a ball -- the forces must balance, meaning that as you pick up a ball your weight increases. But when you see a master of the Force such as Yoda or Darth Vader lift a heavy object, there is no transfer of the weight anywhere.

And while scientists do talk about energy fields in the universe, with names like dark energy and the Higgs field, they aren't anything like the one described in "Star Wars."

Reality check: Unfortunately, it is very unlikely that the Force will be with you.

Death Star/Starkiller Base

In the original "Star Wars" trilogy, two different moon-sized battle stations called Death Stars were said to have the power to destroy a planet. And in 2015's "Star Wars: The Force Awakens," a mobile ice planet called Starkiller Base could destroy several planetary systems across the galaxy in a single shot.

Are those possible?

You can calculate the energy needed for a Death Star to destroy a planet. To destroy the Earth, you'd have to harness the energy output of our Sun for an entire week. That's already challenging, but the Starkiller Base drained the entire energy stored within a star, which is typically emitted over billions of years. Either way, this is a ton of energy to control, but the second one is especially hard to imagine. Somehow Starkiller base absorbed and stored the energy of a star in a location on a planet.

Reality check: No way. That's just crazy talk!

Now, to be fair, we don't watch movies like "Star Wars" to be educated about science or space. We watch them to have a good time, and "The Last Jedi" is the latest in a franchise that has entertained a generation of moviegoers and their children for four decades.

So, don't sweat the science. Grab some popcorn, sit back and enjoy the spectacle.

And may the Force be with you.

Terre Haute
Clear
50° wxIcon
Hi: 50° Lo: 30°
Feels Like: 50°
Robinson
Clear
49° wxIcon
Hi: 49° Lo: 29°
Feels Like: 49°
Indianapolis
Broken Clouds
47° wxIcon
Hi: 48° Lo: 31°
Feels Like: 43°
Rockville
Clear
46° wxIcon
Hi: 49° Lo: 29°
Feels Like: 41°
Casey
Scattered Clouds
49° wxIcon
Hi: 48° Lo: 30°
Feels Like: 47°
Brazil
Clear
50° wxIcon
Hi: 50° Lo: 31°
Feels Like: 50°
Marshall
Clear
50° wxIcon
Hi: 50° Lo: 30°
Feels Like: 50°
Sunny and Cold
WTHI Planner
WTHI Temps
WTHI Radar

Latest Video

Image

Wabash Valley Health Center hosts ribbon cutting

Image

Pandemic hurts working poor families

Image

Uncovering a haunted legend: The Purple Head Bridge

Image

Golden Apple: Jodi Southard

Image

Friday: Mostly sunny and cool. High: 52°

Image

Loogootee volleyball semi-state preview

Image

Vin Lincoln-Sullivan preview

Image

IHSA Basketball moved to Spring

Image

Terre Haute Regional Hospital recognizes its night side nurses

Image

Election leaders are warning you about voter intimidation

WTHI Events

 

Illinois Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 7 p.m. CT)

Confirmed Cases: 400159

Reported Deaths: 9945
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Cook1836495463
DuPage24240617
Lake21608518
Will19516434
Kane17738351
Winnebago10930185
St. Clair8173223
Madison7440157
McHenry6815121
Champaign646228
Peoria483077
Unassigned4770270
McLean432437
Sangamon432264
Rock Island426395
Kankakee358781
Macon344555
Kendall286930
Tazewell285358
LaSalle258467
DeKalb252443
Adams207123
Coles205840
Boone199825
Williamson197961
Clinton185631
Vermilion183011
Whiteside164630
Jackson161126
Knox138221
Randolph133815
Ogle13178
Effingham12664
Marion114723
Stephenson11299
Franklin105910
Grundy10477
Monroe100030
Morgan99925
Bureau95517
Jefferson93952
Henry8697
Christian86830
Macoupin84311
Union80225
McDonough79921
Lee7872
Douglas7429
Shelby73212
Fayette71924
Livingston70711
Woodford69215
Crawford6686
Montgomery65616
Logan6224
Saline6139
Fulton5901
Jo Daviess5479
Warren5419
Iroquois52719
Bond5259
Wayne51915
Jersey48221
Perry47816
Cass47011
Carroll45712
Moultrie4536
Pike4067
Johnson3850
Lawrence3558
Mason3425
Richland34218
Washington3322
Hancock3314
Clay33014
Clark31718
Greene31615
Cumberland3116
Mercer2996
White2794
De Witt2756
Jasper27510
Piatt2731
Pulaski2461
Wabash2436
Ford21115
Menard1881
Marshall1703
Edgar16511
Massac1612
Alexander1451
Hamilton1392
Henderson1320
Brown1220
Edwards1120
Gallatin1122
Scott1120
Putnam980
Schuyler981
Stark943
Calhoun660
Hardin560
Pope431
Out of IL10

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

(Widget updates once daily at 8 p.m. ET)

Confirmed Cases: 172730

Reported Deaths: 4260
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Marion26807796
Lake15074371
St. Joseph10092174
Elkhart9783146
Allen9123235
Hamilton6697120
Vanderburgh640572
Tippecanoe424616
Porter372351
Hendricks3532139
Monroe345038
Johnson3438132
Delaware326378
Clark318865
Vigo293042
Madison270398
LaPorte248867
Cass234426
Kosciusko219529
Warrick212166
Floyd193369
Howard176267
Wayne156933
Dubois155727
Marshall154930
Bartholomew153259
Grant141240
Henry140530
Boone134850
Hancock130244
Noble129335
Jackson125420
Dearborn109728
Lawrence104238
Morgan103040
Gibson98212
Clinton97816
Daviess96036
Shelby95737
Knox89210
LaGrange85115
Fayette84922
Harrison83524
DeKalb82413
Posey8058
Putnam80017
Jasper7395
Miami7205
Steuben7059
Montgomery66622
White65816
Adams6337
Greene60838
Scott57916
Decatur56239
Whitley5216
Ripley5178
Wabash5079
Wells50412
Huntington4985
Clay4927
Starke4929
Sullivan48114
Spencer4436
Randolph43911
Orange43625
Perry42114
Jefferson4165
Fulton4159
Washington4143
Jennings40213
Franklin39625
Jay3816
Pike37018
Carroll36413
Fountain3643
Tipton29423
Vermillion2911
Rush2734
Parke2724
Blackford2555
Newton24411
Owen2251
Martin2070
Pulaski1874
Crawford1691
Brown1523
Ohio1457
Union1280
Benton1160
Switzerland1070
Warren1021
Unassigned0236